CourtListener 10127112•People v. Garcia CA3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 9/30/24 P. v. Garcia CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----
THE PEOPLE, C098001
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 15F06936)
v.
RAFAEL ANTONIO GARCIA,
Defendant and Appellant.
In 2019, a jury found defendant Rafael Antonio Garcia guilty of numerous felonies
including kidnapping with the intent to commit rape and rape by force. The trial court
sentenced defendant to an indeterminate term of 25 years to life, plus a determinate term
of four years eight months. Defendant appealed.
In an unpublished opinion, we reversed one of defendant’s convictions, vacated
the sentence imposed under the One Strike law, and remanded the matter for
resentencing. (People v. Garcia (Mar. 4, 2022, C089036) [nonpub. opn.] (Garcia I).) On
1
remand, the trial court resentenced defendant to an indeterminate term of 15 years to life,
and a determinate term of three years.
On appeal, defendant now contends his convictions must be reversed because the
trial court “did not properly dispose of the doubt as to his competency prior to trial.”
Defendant also contends both trial and former appellate counsel were ineffective for
failing to raise the issue prior to trial and in Garcia I, supra, C089036. We conclude all
three of these claims are beyond the scope of this appeal.
Alternatively, defendant contends the resentencing court erred by not ordering a
second competency evaluation prior to resentencing. We disagree and will affirm the
judgment.
I. BACKGROUND
A. Pre-Trial Competency Hearing
In 2019, defendant was convicted of crimes against three victims. (See Garcia I,
supra, C089036.) Prior to trial, defense counsel raised doubt as to defendant’s
competency. The trial court suspended criminal proceedings and appointed Dr. Jason G.
Roof to evaluate defendant’s competence.
On June 7, 2016, Dr. Roof issued his report. He noted that defendant stopped
school after finishing eleventh grade. Defendant had no recorded history of a learning
disability or “developmental abnormalities,” but he told Dr. Roof that school was hard for
him, and he was held back twice. Dr. Roof observed that defendant demonstrated “fair
insight and judgment” throughout the evaluation and his thought process was “logical and
linear.” Dr. Roof did not conduct an IQ test, but he observed that defendant’s “level of
intelligence appeared lower than average.”
Defendant scored above the passing range on a test of mental competence. And
Dr. Roof reported that defendant “demonstrated an adequate knowledge of criminal
proceedings.” Defendant was able to “understand and describe the roles of key court
participants” and he understood the charges against him. Defendant also was able to
2
respond to Dr. Roof’s questions and apply his understanding of the law to his situation.
Defendant did report seeing and hearing things “ ‘that are not normal.’ ” After further
inquiry and testing, however, Dr. Roof concluded it was unlikely defendant was actually
experiencing hallucinations. It was more likely defendant was malingering.
Based on his observations and findings, Dr. Roof concluded defendant did not
meet the criteria for an active psychiatric disorder. Dr. Roof also concluded defendant
had an “adequate capacity to stand trial[,] . . . understand the nature of the criminal
proceedings, [and] an adequate ability to assist his counsel with his defense.”
Dr. Roof’s report was filed with the trial court on June 20, 2016. The parties
submitted on the report without objection. Based on Dr. Roof’s report, the trial court
found defendant competent to stand trial and reinstated criminal proceedings. Ultimately,
a jury found defendant guilty of kidnapping with the intent to commit rape and/or sexual
penetration (Pen. Code, § 209, subd. (b)(1)),1 two counts of forcible sexual penetration
(§ 289, subd. (a)(1)), attempted rape (§§ 664/261, subd. (a)(2)), lewd acts on a child
(§ 288, subd. (c)(1)), and battery (§ 242). (Garcia I, supra, C089036.)
B. Sentencing
Prior to sentencing, defendant was referred to Dr. Eugene Roeder for a
psychological evaluation to determine whether defendant had a “mental disorder” that
may have impacted his “interpretation” of the criminal conduct underlying his
convictions. On June 20, 2018, Dr. Roeder issued his report. Defense counsel attached
Dr. Roeder’s report to their statement in mitigation.
In his report, Dr. Roeder noted that evaluating defendant was difficult because
defendant was evasive and gave insufficiently detailed responses to questions. Dr.
Roeder also noted that during the evaluation, it appeared defendant’s ability to
1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
3
concentrate and attend to the conversation was “impaired.” Dr. Roeder reported that
defendant appeared to be of “below average intelligence” and his score on intelligence
testing “suggested a mild intellectual disability.”
Defendant told Dr. Roeder he stopped going to school after eleventh grade but did
not explain why. When discussing his case, defendant told Dr. Roeder he was surprised
when he was arrested. He also said that after talking to his counsel, he thought there
were five cases pending against him. Defendant said there were no plea discussions with
his counsel and explained that he only attends court “ ‘when they take [him].’ ”
Defendant expressed confusion about why he was in jail and when asked about
medication, he said, “ ‘They have been barely giving me a pill.’ ”
After evaluating defendant, Dr. Roeder opined defendant was likely sane when he
committed the offenses for which he was convicted; however, defendant “is clearly an
individual who suffers from a severe mental disorder that could and would affect his
interpretation of events.” Defendant’s substance abuse “exasperate[d] his symptoms, and
caused him to be even more disturbed.” Dr. Roeder concluded that defendant’s “mental
illness” is “chronic and severe, and as a result he is likely to experience ongoing
challenges for the foreseeable future.”
At sentencing, the trial court considered defendant’s statement in mitigation,
including Dr. Roeder’s report. The trial court then sentenced defendant to a one-strike
term of 25 years to life for forcible sexual penetration, a four-year term for attempted
forcible rape, and an eight-month term for lewd acts on a child. (Garcia I, supra,
C089036.)
C. Resentencing
Defendant appealed from the judgment. On appeal, this court reversed
defendant’s conviction for lewd acts on a child, vacated the sentence imposed under the
One Strike law, and remanded the matter for resentencing. (Garcia I, supra, C089036.)
4
On remand, the resentencing court resentenced defendant to a term of 15 years to life,
plus three years.2
At the resentencing hearing, defendant appeared via Zoom, and his attorney was
physically present in the courtroom. After reminding defendant to take himself off mute,
the following exchange took place between defendant, the court, and counsel: “The
record shall reflect that the Court has reviewed the remittitur in this matter[,] the previous
probation report[,] and previous judgment and sentence. And the remittitur is filed as part
of the record in this case.
“[THE COURT]: [H]ave you received a copy of the remittitur and have you had
an adequate time to . . . review [it] with [defendant]?
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: I do not know if [defendant] has gotten any of my
letters because he’s at California state prison Los Angeles, and he is—they have four
facilities. I don’t know what facility he’s in. I [d]id send a letter to each one of the
facilities.
“Did you get a letter from me, [defendant]?
“And did you also get a copy of my sentencing memorandum that I dated January
12? Looks like this.
“THE COURT: Holding a letter.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Can you speak?
“THE COURT: [Defendant], is that a letter you received from [defense counsel]?
“THE DEFENDANT: This is one. I have one. I have three more. This is one
here.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: I’m guessing he got all four.
2 The court stayed a term of seven years to life on defendant’s conviction for kidnapping
with the intent to rape as well as a term of 15 years to life on defendant’s second
conviction for forcible sexual penetration.
5
“THE COURT: Do they contain a sentencing memo?
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: I sent –
“THE COURT: Did you receive a sentencing memo like this, [defendant], from
your attorney?
“THE DEFENDANT: I’m having problems with the image. I can’t see you guys.
I can hear you a little bit. Something wrong with the video.
“THE COURT: Somebody will assist you with that.
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah, give me a second.
“THE COURT: Are you ready?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah.
“THE COURT: Okay. I’m going to start.”
The resentencing court confirmed defense counsel reviewed the decision on appeal
as well as the sentencing transcript and probation report, then asked whether counsel had
sufficient opportunity to discuss the issues with defendant. Counsel indicated he sent
defendant both his analysis of the remittitur and a sentencing memo. Defendant then
raised his hand to speak: “Yeah. I received a letter. A lot of these papers legal
paperwork something about a lot of things, a lot of whatever—say whatever they talking
about, all the time serving I’ve been here eight years. I was in County. Came back to
prison for eight years. What I was asking about with the lawyer I had before, a lot of
these things I never—false statements. Trying to explain to her, I had all these counts. A
lot of all these counts, these statements before are different. It was something different.
“This is my—I have a lot to talk about that. What I’m saying everything that they
have against me what they’re saying I did, what I did for my case, my crimes, all these
whatever they say all that, this is what they say. What I’m saying is a lot is false.
“I got the letter from him, legal paperwork with my all my info, everything with
the same address, name everything. I have the letter. There is the—what is it? Yeah.
Letter right here. Resentencing today, right?
6
“THE COURT: Yes.
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah. At this time?
“THE COURT: Yes.
“THE DEFENDANT: This is the last one I have.
“THE COURT: Okay.
“THE DEFENDANT: This is what—what is happening today?
“THE COURT: Yes.
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay. What is happening now?
“THE COURT: We’re going to do the resentencing based on the Court of Appeal
sending back your case saying we need to resentence differently.
“THE DEFENDANT: Anything I can do to help me? Something that I’m not
comfortable with, something I’m not agreeing with.
“THE COURT: Hold on. [Defense counsel] sent a copy of his resentencing
memo. Did you get a copy of this?
“THE DEFENDANT: This is one I’m showing. That’s the one I have.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Does it have my name—no. That’s a letter.
“Do you have a document that has –
“THE DEFENDANT: I have a letter.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Sir –
“THE COURT: [Defendant], let your attorney talk to you. Just be quiet for [a]
second. He’ll talk to you.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Do you have the document that is maybe about an
eighth of an inch thick, has an attachment, has my name and address at top left-hand
corner. It says defendant sentencing memorandum. Do you have that?
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah. Sacramento, in envelope. I have it in the cell. In the
cell I have it.
“THE COURT: Did you read it?
7
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah. Read that. Yeah. I have in there.
“THE COURT: Okay. That’s your attorney’s argument for you with regard to
resentence.
“THE DEFENDANT: What do you want to do now?
“THE COURT: I’m going to resentence you. Okay. I’m going to resentence you
based on the law which I think you’re going to have a difficult time understanding, but
I’m going to try to do it in a way that makes you understand what we’re doing here today.
Okay.
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah. Okay. Okay. Yeah, I got his letter.
“THE COURT: You have his legal document that he sent you in your cell.
“THE DEFENDANT: I need a lawyer. Is he Joseph? Yeah. I have it.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: That’s me.
“THE DEFENDANT: Yeah.
“THE COURT: Okay.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: I think I can do this right now. [Defendant,] what’s
going to happen is you were sentenced to 25 years to life. That I believe is going to go
away. You were also sentenced to life on the kidnap case. That can’t change, but I do
believe the 25 years to life is no longer going to be imposed on you. You’re going to get
a substantial reduction in the sentence that you were given previously. That’s what this
resentencing is going to do in my opinion.
“Did you hear that?
“THE DEFENDANT: What’s going to happen?
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: The judge is going to resentence you, and you’re going
to be sentenced to a lot less time than you got before.
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay.
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: That’s what today is for.
“THE DEFENDANT: Oh –
8
“[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: At the direction of the Court of Appeal. We are not
retrying your case. Your case was affirmed on appeal. The Court of Appeal simply said
you have to be resentenced to less time. That’s what today is all about. Okay?
“THE DEFENDANT: That’s good.
“THE COURT: You’re going to listen right now. Okay.
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay.”
Counsel for both parties submitted and the resentencing court asked defendant if
he wanted to be heard:
“THE DEFENDANT: You asked me?
“THE COURT: Yeah. We’ve heard from you. Just going to impose the new
sentence. I just wanted to know if there’s anything else you want to say about the
sentence, not necessarily about the trial.
“THE DEFENDANT: I’m getting something else, more paper with a notice?
“THE COURT: You will get something once we’re done here.
“THE DEFENDANT: About this charge today, right?
“THE COURT: Yes.
“THE DEFENDANT: I don’t [know] what else is going on for today.
“THE COURT: Okay.
“Okay. I’ll go forward with sentencing. You will get a notice of what we did
today, and you can take a look at it and talk to [defense counsel] about it, and then you’ll
have a better understanding of what we’re doing.
“I’ll try to explain as I go. Okay?
“THE DEFENDANT: Okay. Okay.”
The resentencing court then resentenced defendant to an aggregate term of 15
years to life plus three years. The court awarded defendant custody credits, imposed
various fines and fees, and advised defendant of his right to appeal. When asked if he
9
understood his right to appeal, defendant responded, “I got it.” The court also asked
defendant if he understood his parole rights:
“[THE COURT:] Do you understand what I said about your parole rights?
“THE DEFENDANT: Write it down. I can’t think. Put on the paper. Can I read
them. I can remember.”
The court then advised defendant about his parole rights a second time.
Defendant appeals from his resentencing.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Issues Not Cognizable on Appeal
As an initial matter, we find three of defendant’s four appellate contentions to be
beyond the scope of this appeal.
First, absent good cause or justification, a defendant may not raise an issue in a
second appeal that could have been raised in the first appeal. (See People v. Senior
(1995) 33 Cal.App.4th 531, 538 [“where a criminal defendant could have raised an issue
in a prior appeal, the appellate court need not entertain the issue in a subsequent appeal
absent a showing of justification for the delay”].) An issue not raised in a prior appeal is
waived in a subsequent appeal where “(1) the issue was ripe for decision by the appellate
court at the time of the previous appeal; (2) there has been no significant change in the
underlying facts or applicable law; and (3) the defendant has offered no reasonable
justification for the delay.” (Ibid.)
Here, defendant contends the trial court erred in finding him competent to stand
trial without further inquiry. Defendant could have raised this claim in his prior appeal
but did not. (See People v. Fields (1965) 62 Cal.2d 538, 541-542 [determination of
competence may be reviewed on appeal from a judgment of conviction]; see also Garcia
I, supra, C089036.) Defendant claims he had strong justification for not raising the issue
in his prior appeal because “the grounds for appealing the issue of his pretrial
competency arguably did not become overly apparent until resentencing.” However, he
10
relies primarily on the same two doctors’ reports the trial court considered when it found
defendant competent before trial. The only “new” information he offers is his conduct at
resentencing, which, on this record, does not justify the delay.
Defendant also claims trial counsel was ineffective for failing to challenge the trial
court’s competency finding before trial. Again, defendant could have asserted this claim
in Garcia I but did not. He offers no justification for failing to do so.
In addition, defendant argues that prior appellate counsel was ineffective for
failing to challenge the trial court’s competency finding in Garcia I. Any claim that prior
appellate counsel was ineffective must be raised in a postappeal habeas corpus petition.
(See In re Hampton (2020) 48 Cal.App.5th 463, 474.) Accordingly, this claim also is not
cognizable on this appeal.
Finally, acknowledging these claims may be beyond the scope of this appeal,
defendant invites this court to exercise its inherent discretion to nevertheless consider
these claims. We decline his invitation.
B. Competency at Resentencing
Defendant also argues the resentencing court erred by not conducting a second
competency evaluation on remand, prior to resentencing. He claims that his conduct at
the resentencing hearing, along with the prior two doctors’ reports, triggered the
resentencing court’s obligation to evaluate his competency. We disagree.
“ ‘Penal Code section 1368 requires that criminal proceedings be suspended and
competency proceedings be commenced if “a doubt arises in the mind of the judge”
regarding the defendant's competence (id., subd. (a)) and defense counsel concurs (id.,
subd. (b)).’ ” (People v. Wycoff (2021) 12 Cal.5th 58, 82.)
However, “the duty to suspend is not triggered by information that substantially
duplicates evidence already considered at an earlier, formal inquiry into the defendant’s
competence, and that when faced with evidence of relatively minor changes in the
defendant’s mental state, the court may rely on a prior competency finding rather than
11
convening a new hearing to cover largely the same ground.” (In re Sims (2021) 67
Cal.App.5th 762, 783.) “[W]hen a defendant has already been found competent to stand
trial, ‘ “a trial court need not suspend proceedings to conduct a second competency
hearing unless it ‘is presented with a substantial change of circumstances or with new
evidence’ casting a serious doubt on the validity of that finding.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
Further, “once a defendant has been found to be competent, even bizarre
statements and actions are not enough to require a further inquiry.” (People v. Marks
(2003) 31 Cal.4th 197, 220.) Nor is an appellate court in a position “ ‘ “ ‘to appraise a
defendant’s conduct in the trial court as indicating insanity, a calculated attempt to feign
insanity and delay the proceedings, or sheer temper.’ ” ’ ” (Ibid.) Accordingly,
“[r]eviewing courts give great deference to a trial court’s decision whether to hold a
competency hearing.” (Ibid.)
On remand, defendant appeared via Zoom, which created some initial confusion
related to technical difficulties. Defendant also expressed some confusion about why he
was in court. The court and counsel walked defendant through the reason he was there
and made sure he had received and reviewed the documents counsel sent him. On this
record, it appears defendant came to understand what was happening, and he understood
it was good news because his sentence was being reduced.
Contrary to defendant’s claim on appeal, whatever confusion he exhibited at
resentencing appears to be no more than any lay person would exhibit given the
complicated process of appeal, remittitur, and resentencing. Moreover, it may be that
defendant struggled to hear the resentencing court and counsel because he was on Zoom
and not in the room. On appeal, we do not have the benefit of knowing exactly how well
the remote connection was working, nor do we have the benefit of witnessing defendant’s
demeanor or hearing him speak.
In short, we cannot assess whether defendant was actually confused, the extent of
his confusion, or how much of that confusion was the result of delays and/or glitches in
12
the Zoom technology. The resentence court was better positioned to make those
assessments. Accordingly, we give deference to their decision, and find no error.
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
/S/
RENNER, J.
We concur:
/S/
EARL, P. J.
/S/
ROBIE, J.
13
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.