CourtListener 10124265•In re J.V. CA2/2
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 9/23/24 In re J.V. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re J.V., a Person Coming B332842
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
17CCJP02604E)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff,
v.
C.L.,
Defendant and Appellant;
J.V.,
Respondent.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Tiana J. Murillo, Judge. Affirmed.
Janelle B. Price, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Janette Freeman Cochran, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, for Respondent.
________________________________
C.L. (father) appeals from the juvenile court’s October 25,
2023 dispositional order releasing his then 11-year-old daughter
J.V., the respondent in this appeal, to him and to J.V.’s mother
Claudia (mother).1 Father contends J.V. should have remained
placed in his sole custody. We affirm the juvenile court’s order.
BACKGROUND
Prior child welfare history
In December 2017, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (Department) filed a petition under
Welfare and Institutions Code2 section 300, subdivisions (a) and
(b) on behalf of J.V. and her two half siblings, V.V. and X.V.,3
alleging domestic violence between mother and Milton, the father
of X.V. The juvenile court sustained the petition and ordered J.V.
1 Neither mother nor the Los Angeles County Department
of Children and Family Services are parties to this appeal.
2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code, unless stated otherwise.
3 Neither V.V. nor X.V. is a subject of or party to this
appeal.
2
placed with father while mother participated in reunification
services.
In August 2018, the Department filed a subsequent petition
pursuant to section 342 alleging sexual abuse of V.V. by Milton,
physical abuse of J.V. by Milton, and mother’s failure to protect
the children from Milton’s abuse. The juvenile court sustained
the petition and placed J.V. in the respective homes of father and
mother. The court ordered mother to participate in individual
therapy and sexual abuse awareness classes. The juvenile court
further ordered no contact between Milton and J.V. or V.V.
In May 2019, the Department filed a supplemental petition
pursuant to section 387, alleging that mother continued to allow
Milton access to the children. The May 19 petition was dismissed
without prejudice in July 2019. J.V. remained placed with both
mother and father with family maintenance services. The
juvenile court terminated jurisdiction in May 2021 and accorded
both parents joint legal and physical custody of J.V., with
mother’s home as J.V.’s primary residence.
Current case
Detention and section 300 petition
In May 2023, the Department received a referral alleging
sexual abuse of J.V. by Milton and general neglect by mother.
The reporting party observed J.V. crying after school. J.V.
disclosed that Milton had been touching her inappropriately on
her thighs and breasts for the past month. Milton was picking
J.V. up after school that day, and she did not want to go with
him.
In a May 10, 2023 interview, J.V. told the Department’s
social worker that mother had resumed a relationship with
Milton in August 2022. Milton thereafter began picking up J.V.
3
and X.V. from school on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays.
He sometimes took the children to his home after school. J.V.
stated that Milton had touched her breasts and thighs several
times during the past month. Although Milton made her feel
uncomfortable, J.V. did not disclose the touching because she
thought no one would believe her. J.V. reported that mother hit
her and her siblings with a belt across the buttocks
approximately five times a month between 2016 and 2022 for not
following her directives. The last time mother hit them with a
belt was in September 2022. J.V. nevertheless reported feeling
safe in mother’s home. She said she occasionally spent the
weekend at father’s home, where she also felt safe.
That same day, the social worker interviewed V.V., who
confirmed that Milton had been picking up J.V. and X.V. from
school since November 2022. V.V. reported that in May 2022,
Milton took her and her half siblings to Griffith Park, where
Milton grabbed V.V. and kissed her with his tongue. She did not
disclose the incident because she did not want the Department to
take her siblings away. V.V. said she last saw Milton in January
2023 when he took the children to Big Bear.
In a May 10, 2023 interview, mother told the social worker
that Milton resumed contact with the family three months ago.
She confirmed that Milton transported J.V. and X.V. home after
school. She denied any knowledge of Milton touching or kissing
any of the children inappropriately or taking them to Griffith
Park. Mother denied hitting the children. She admitted a single
incident in which she hit all three children with a belt across
their buttocks but left no marks or bruises on them.
The social worker reinterviewed J.V. on May 17, 2023. The
child confirmed that in January 2023, Milton and two of his
4
friends had taken her and the siblings to Big Bear, where they
stayed for four or five hours. Mother knew about the Big Bear
outing but had not accompanied them because she was working
that day. J.V. said she had had no contact with Milton since
May 10, 2023.
On May 23, 2023, the Department filed a petition under
section 300, subdivisions (a), (b), (d), and (j) on behalf of J.V. and
her half siblings alleging sexual abuse of J.V. and V.V. by Milton,
physical abuse of the children by mother, and mother’s failure to
protect the children from Milton’s abuse. On May 26, 2023, the
juvenile court granted the Department’s application for a
warrant removing J.V. and her siblings from mother’s home.
On June 2, 2023, the juvenile court ordered J.V. detained
from mother and released to father. The court also issued a
temporary restraining order protecting mother and the children
from Milton.
Jurisdiction and disposition
In a June 22, 2023 interview, J.V. told the Department’s
social worker mother would hit her with a belt, leaving red marks
that would last for one to two days. Mother did so every few
weeks from the time J.V. was four or five years old until age 9.
J.V. confirmed that Milton began transporting her and X.V.
from school in August 2022. Milton also took J.V. and her
siblings to Griffith Park on four or five occasions. He took the
children to Big Bear with two of his male friends in January
2023. J.V. reported feeling sad because she was no longer living
with mother. She and her siblings all wanted to return to
mother’s care.
Mother denied hitting the children with a belt but said she
had threatened to do so. She also denied knowing that Milton
5
was sexually abusing J.V. or V.V. She acknowledged that she
should not have allowed Milton access to the children.
Father told the social worker that he did not have a
relationship with mother and did not live with her. He was not
aware that mother had physically abused the children or that
Milton had sexually abused J.V. or V.V. Father did not know of
J.V.’s existence until after the child was born. He confirmed his
paternity with a DNA test and helped mother purchase formula,
diapers, and clothes for J.V. Mother ceased contact with father
after she met Milton, and father had no relationship with J.V. for
three years. Father was currently married with two adult
children. Father wanted sole legal and physical custody of J.V.
because he did not trust mother, given her history and the
current allegations of physical and sexual abuse.
The Department recommended that J.V. receive individual
and family therapy and remain released to father. The
Department further recommended that mother be granted
reunification services, including parenting education, sexual
abuse awareness counseling and individual therapy, and
monitored visitation with Departmental discretion to liberalize
the visits.
Adjudication and disposition hearing
Mother, father, J.V., and the siblings were present at the
October 25, 2023 combined adjudication and disposition hearing.
The juvenile court admitted into evidence the Department’s
exhibits and forensic interview transcripts for V.V. and J.V.
submitted by father. The court took judicial notice of the case
file. After hearing argument from counsel for the parties, the
juvenile court sustained the allegations that mother failed to
protect the children from sexual abuse by Milton and dismissed
6
the physical abuse allegations, finding insufficient evidence of
any recent physical abuse.
The juvenile court then moved to disposition. The court
accepted stipulated testimony by mother that she was enrolled in
sexual abuse awareness and parenting classes and had completed
14 of 16 sexual abuse awareness classes and 14 of 16 parenting
classes. At the Department’s recommendation, mother had also
enrolled in a new sexual abuse awareness and parenting program
with a different provider. She had attended one parenting class
and one sexual abuse awareness class in the new program and
would continue to do so on a weekly basis. Mother would not
allow Milton to have contact with the children except monitored
visits with X.V.
Father’s counsel asked that J.V. be placed in father’s home
because the Department had proven by clear and convincing
evidence that J.V. should not be returned to mother. Counsel
noted that in the previous case involving Milton’s sexual abuse of
V.V., mother had completed a sexual abuse awareness program,
claimed to be aware of her past mistakes, and said she would not
place her daughters at risk. Immediately thereafter, mother had
allowed Milton back into the children’s lives. Father’s counsel
argued that mother had not gained insight and that returning
J.V. to her care was premature.
J.V.’s counsel asked that J.V. be released to mother, noting
that mother had been participating in services for nearly five
months, and that J.V. and her siblings had demonstrated that
they would readily disclose any abuse. Counsel further noted
that the children were seeing a therapist, who was an additional
mandated reporter should future issues arise. Finally, J.V.
wanted to be reunited with mother and her siblings.
7
Mother’s counsel requested return of the children to
mother’s care. Counsel stated that mother assumed full
responsibility for her past conduct and was very remorseful.
Mother was taking measures to safeguard the children by
seeking a permanent restraining order against Milton and
enrolling in additional parenting and sexual abuse classes. She
would not allow contact between the children and Milton except
for court-ordered monitored visits with X.V. Counsel also noted
that the children loved mother and were clearly bonded with her.
The Department’s counsel argued for continued detention
of the children from mother. Counsel noted that although mother
had completed sexual abuse awareness counseling, it was the
same program she had completed in the previous case involving
V.V. Although mother had enrolled in a new sexual abuse
awareness program, she had only recently begun classes in the
new program. Counsel expressed concern about mother’s work
schedule and the children’s care, noting that in the past mother
had resorted to relying on Milton’s help in caring for the children.
Counsel argued against releasing the children to mother absent
an appropriate plan for the children’s care while mother was at
work.
The juvenile court stated it had considered the evidence
and the parties’ arguments and declared J.V. and her siblings to
be dependent children subject to the Department’s supervision.
The court found the Department had made reasonable efforts to
prevent further removal of the children from mother and that
reasonable services were available to prevent their further
removal. The juvenile court ordered J.V. released to both mother
and father. The court ordered mother to complete sexual abuse
awareness counseling in her new program, parenting, individual
8
counseling and high-conflict parenting classes to address any
coparenting issues with father concerning J.V. The juvenile court
noted that subjecting the family to both the Department’s
supervision and the court’s supervision provided adequate
protection for the children against any further lapses in judgment
by mother in allowing Milton access to the children.
The juvenile court then considered mother’s request for a
permanent restraining order against Milton and granted the
request as to J.V. and her siblings.
This appeal followed.
DISCUSSION
I. Applicable law and standard of review
Section 361, subdivision (c) provides in part: “A dependent
child shall not be taken from the physical custody of his or her
parents . . . with whom the child resides at the time the petition
was initiated, unless the juvenile court finds clear and convincing
evidence . . . [that] . . . [¶] . . . [t]here is or would be a substantial
danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned
home, and there are no reasonable means by which the minor’s
physical health can be protected without removing the minor
from the minor’s parent’s … physical custody.” (§ 361, subd.
(c)(1).) The statute “embodies the Legislature’s preference for
‘ “maintaining children in their natural parent’s homes where it
[is] safe to do so.” ’ ” (In re D.P. (2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 1058,
1068.) Under section 361, subdivision (c), the juvenile court
cannot remove a dependent child from the physical custody of the
“parents . . . with whom the child resides,” unless the court finds
(1) the child would be substantially endangered if “returned
home”; and (2) “removing an offending parent ... from the home”
9
is not a reasonable means to protect the child if the child is
“returned home.” (§ 361, subd. (c)(1), (c)(1)(A).)
Although the substantial evidence test typically applies to
review of a removal order under section 361 (In re M.V. (2022) 78
Cal.App.5th 944, 960), a different standard applies when the
juvenile court has expressly or implicitly concluded that the
burden of proof was not met. (See In re I.W. (2009) 180
Cal.App.4th 1517, 1527 (I.W.), disapproved on another ground by
Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1011, fn. 7.) As the
court in I.W. noted, the substantial evidence test “is typically
implicated when a defendant contends that the plaintiff
succeeded at trial in spite of insufficient evidence. In the case
where the trier of fact has expressly or implicitly concluded that
the party with the burden of proof did not carry the burden and
that party appeals, it is misleading to characterize the failure-of-
proof issue as whether substantial evidence supports the
judgment. This follows because such a characterization is
conceptually one that allows an attack on (1) the evidence
supporting the party who had no burden of proof, and (2) the trier
of fact’s unassailable conclusion that the party with the burden
did not prove one or more elements of the case [citations]. [¶] . . .
[W]here the issue on appeal turns on a failure of proof at trial,
the question for a reviewing court becomes whether the evidence
compels a finding in favor of the appellant as a matter of law.
[Citations.] Specifically, the question becomes whether the
appellant’s evidence was (1) ‘uncontradicted and unimpeached’
and (2) ‘of such a character and weight as to leave no room for a
judicial determination that it was insufficient to support a
finding.’ ” (I.W., at p. 1528.)
10
J.V. argues that the standard articulated in I.W. does not
apply because the appellant in that case was also the party who
bore the burden of proof in the juvenile court proceedings
whereas here the Department bore the burden of proof and only
father appeals the dispositional order. That same argument was
rejected by the court in In re Luis H. (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 1223
(Luis H.). The appellants in Luis H. were minors appealing the
juvenile court’s dismissal of a section 300 petition alleging they
were at risk of harm because their mother failed to protect their
sibling from sexual abuse by a male companion. Although the
Department bore the burden of proof at the jurisdictional
hearing, and only the minors appealed the dismissal, the court in
Luis H. did not find that factual distinction warranted a different
standard of review. (Id. at p. 1226.) The court in Luis H. noted
that children who are the subject of dependency petitions and
their appointed counsel have the right to present evidence, and to
summon, confront, and cross-examine witnesses at the
adjudicatory and dispositional hearing. Because the minors had
the opportunity to produce evidence and create a record that
supported their position, the court in Luis H. found “no reason to
depart from the general rule that ‘where the issue on appeal
turns on a failure of proof at trial, the question for a reviewing
court becomes whether the evidence compels a finding in favor of
the appellant as a matter of law.’ ” (Id. at p. 1227.)
We find the courts’ reasoning in I.W. and Luis H.
persuasive and apply it here. We must therefore affirm the
challenged dispositional order unless the evidence compels a
finding in father’s favor as a matter of law. (I.W., supra, 180
Cal.App.4th at p. 1528; Luis H., supra, 14 Cal.App.5th at
p. 1227.)
11
II. The evidence does not compel a finding in father’s
favor
The evidence does not compel a finding in father’s favor as
a matter of law. As support for his position, father cites evidence
of mother’s failure to protect V.V. from Milton’s abuse in the prior
case and her failure to protect J.V. from Milton in the current
case. The juvenile court considered mother’s prior case history
and mother’s repetition of her mistakes in the current case.
Against that evidence, the juvenile court weighed and considered
additional evidence, including mother’s five-month participation
in parenting and sexual abuse counseling, her enrollment in
additional parenting and sexual abuse counseling classes with a
different provider, mother’s acceptance of responsibility and
remorse for her previous failings, her commitment to prohibit
contact between Milton and the children, the strong bond
between mother and J.V., and J.V.’s strong bond with her
siblings. The juvenile court also took into consideration
additional safeguards for the children’s protection, including a
permanent restraining order against Milton, the children’s
enrollment in therapy and their therapist’s obligation to report
any future abuse, the children’s demonstrated willingness to
disclose abuse, and continuing supervision by both the
Department and the juvenile court.
Father contends a restraining order is not sufficient to
protect J.V. because a court order issued against Milton in the
previous case failed to protect her and mother’s willingness to
enforce a new restraining order is questionable. Father further
contends mother’s remorse concerning her past mistakes is not
genuine and she cannot be relied upon to protect J.V. in the
future. We do not revisit the juvenile court’s assessment of
12
mother’s credibility and do not reevaluate conflicting or
competing evidence when reviewing the juvenile court’s failure of
proof determination. (In re Aurora P. (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th
1142, 1164; I.W., supra, 180 Cal.App.4th at p. 1528.) “This is not
a case ‘where undisputed facts lead to only one conclusion.’ ”
(Aurora P., at p. 1164.) Father did not sustain his burden of
presenting evidence “ ‘of such a character and weight as to leave
no room for a judicial determination that it was insufficient’ ” to
support the juvenile court’s determination. (I.W., at p. 1528.)
DISPOSITION
The October 25, 2023 dispositional order releasing J.V. to
both her parents is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
CHAVEZ, J.
HOFFSTADT, J.
13
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.