CourtListener 10122944•In re C.H. CA5
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 9/20/24 In re C.H. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re C.H. et al., Persons Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.
FRESNO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF F086801
SOCIAL SERVICES,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 23CEJ300089-1,
Plaintiff and Respondent, 23CEJ300089-2, 23CEJ300089-3,
23CEJ300089-4)
v.
C.H., OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Fresno County. Amythest
Freeman, Judge.
Judith A. Carlson, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant.
Daniel C. Cederborg, County Counsel, and Ashley N. McGuire, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
* Before Franson, Acting P. J., Peña, J. and Meehan, J.
INTRODUCTION
Appellant C.H. (mother) is mother of four children, sons C.S. (age 13),
S.H. (age 11), E.H. (age 9), and daughter S.O. (age 9).1 The father is presumed to have
passed away in May 2022. The children were removed from mother’s care after she was
placed on a Welfare and Institutions Code, section 51502 hold, and subsequently detained
and removed from mother’s care. Mother argues substantial evidence does not support
the juvenile court’s finding that there was a substantial danger to the children’s physical
health, safety, protection or physical or emotional well-being if they were returned home.
Additionally, mother argues there was not substantial evidence there were no reasonable
means by which the children’s physical health could be protected without removal, or that
reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal.
We find substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s finding by clear and
convincing evidence that there was a substantial danger to the children’s physical health,
safety, protection or physical or emotional well-being if they were returned to mother’s
care, and reasonable efforts were made to prevent the need for removal and were
ineffective. We affirm the juvenile court’s August 23, 2023 disposition and jurisdiction
order.
PROCEDURAL AND FACTUAL HISTORY
Juvenile Dependency Petition
On April 4, 2023, the Fresno County Department of Social Services (the
department) filed a section 300 petition alleging the children suffered, or there was a
substantial risk that the children would suffer, serious physical harm or illness as a result
of mother’s failure or inability to supervise or protect the children adequately (§ 300,
subd. (b)(1)(A)), and as a result of mother’s failure or inability to provide regular care for
1 Together “the children.”
2 Undesignated references to code are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2.
the children due to mother’s mental illness, developmental disability, or substance abuse
(§ 300, subd. (b)(1)(D)).
The petition alleged mother had untreated mental health issues which hindered her
ability to provide regular care, supervision, and protection for her children. The petition
stated that on April 2, 2023, mother was placed on a section 5150 hold for being in a
manic state because she was unable to regulate her emotions or heart rate. Mother also
had a history of suicidal ideation, self-harm and being placed on section 5150 holds, and
the children were at substantial risk of suffering serious physical harm or neglect if left in
mother’s care.
Events Preceding the April 5, 2023 Detention Hearing
On April 2, 2023, at approximately 1:00 p.m., social worker Jenifer Moore
responded to the Fresno Police Department and met with Officer Rodriguez and
behavioral health clinician Jaime Carlos from Kings View Behavioral Clinic (Kings
View). Rodriguez informed Moore that C.S. was brought to the police station by a family
friend. Mother had called the friend and said she could not have C.S. in the home and
wanted the friend to take C.S. “ ‘somewhere’ ” without specifying where or for how long.
C.S. had reportedly been having behavioral problems since father’s passing in May 2022.
The friend tried to take C.S. to “the Sanctuary”3 but it was closed. The friend then
brought C.S. to the police station and asked for resources.
Rodriguez called Kings View but was informed C.S. did not meet the criteria for a
section 5150 hold. Rodriguez then called mother, who said C.S. could not return home.
She did agree to come to the station with her other children.
At the station, mother maintained that C.S. could not return home but was unable
to provide a reason. During her conversation with Rodriguez, she began to cry
3 Sanctuary Transitional Shelter is an unhoused or otherwise displaced youth and
young adult shelter operating in Fresno, California.
3.
“hysterically” and fell to the ground. She repeated that C.S. could not go home with her
because he “does not like her” but could not otherwise provide a coherent explanation
why she did not want C.S. home.
Carlos indicated mother was in a manic state because she was unable to regulate
her emotions or heart rate. Mother did not report prior mental health issues or diagnoses
to Carlos. When asked whether she had knowledge of a section 5150 hold, mother
smiled and refused to speak. Mother was taken to a crisis stabilization center, while
screaming that her children could not go into foster care because S.O. was a female and
would be molested.
Moore spoke with the children at the department office. C.S. denied any
inappropriate physical contact and said he always has enough food to eat and clothing to
wear. He denied that mother uses drugs or alcohol. When asked why he was picked up
by the family friend earlier that morning, C.S. stated that he yelled at mother when she
woke him up. C.S. stated that mother wanted him to clean, but he did not want to, and
that mother had been “ ‘stressed out’ ” since father’s death. C.S. said mother does not
always sleep or eat. C.S. said two years earlier, mother and father were having an
argument and mother cut herself with something sharp, and C.S. was worried she would
do that again. He also remembered that two years earlier, mother had asked C.S. to get
her a crowbar and she proceeded to break father’s car windows with it. Another time,
mother broke father’s car mirrors and was arrested.
S.H. similarly did not have any negative comments about his care or home life but
was worried that mother spent a lot of time on her phone talking to her boyfriend who
lived in Ghana. E.H. and S.O. also did not have any negative comments about their care
or home life, and stated they had no worries except for E.H., who was worried about
mother because she was taken away by ambulance.
On April 3, 2023, social worker Katrina Martinez spoke to mother by telephone.
Mother stated she was not aware why she was placed on a section 5150 hold, and that she
4.
was not suicidal. When asked about what happened on April 2, 2023, mother said she
and the children were going to visit the children’s grandmother at the hospital, and C.S.
was being defiant. He made a “piercing scream noise” and when mother told C.S. that
the residents in the upstairs unit might be asleep, C.S. said he “sometimes has to scream.”
Mother called the maternal grandfather, Delbert W., to talk with C.S., but C.S. refused to
talk to him.
Mother then called the family friend to take C.S. and took the other children to get
bagels. Mother believed she felt C.S. needed to be removed from her home “for some
time.” After receiving a phone call from the police, mother went to the police station
with her children. She said she cried at one point in her conversation with the officers
and clinician, but the clinician “misconstrued” her crying. She told the clinician that her
menstrual cycle was going to begin soon but the clinician didn’t accept her response and
that is why she was placed on a section 5150 hold.
Mother confirmed father passed away from cancer on May 17, 2022. She stated
she was not suicidal because “God ha[d] given her strength.” She did confirm that
three years before she felt suicidal and had been placed on a section 5150 hold. When
asked how she was able to stabilize herself afterward, mother answered in a vague
manner, that she had felt “validated with those feelings” and she was “empowered to not
feel that way and to rise above those feelings.” She denied any current mental diagnoses
or challenges, although she confirmed being diagnosed with an anxiety disorder in the
past. She also used to take melatonin to help her sleep, but she no longer needed it.
Mother stated she was attending grief counseling, and C.S. had previously
received grief counseling but stopped due to a scheduling conflict. Mother denied any of
her children take medication and stated that C.S. was diagnosed with oppositional
defiance disorder in 2021. Mother denied drug and alcohol use and stated she had been
arrested for domestic violence one time about three years ago when she knocked a phone
out of the father’s hand. She took classes and the charge was dismissed.
5.
C.S. had previously stayed with Delbert in San Francisco for approximately
six months, and had done well, but mother said she decided to return him to her care
when Delbert went on a vacation. Delbert was willing to take C.S. back but he did not
have a car.
Mother explained that she was not in a manic state at the police station, and that it
was “ ‘that person’s opinion.’ ” She had been walking around while talking to Rodriguez
and Carlos to “get some exercise” and she had not been “ ‘bad.’ ” She wanted the
children, including C.S., to be returned to her care. In the meantime, mother
recommended the children be placed with Yazmin R., a family friend whose children
attended the same school as the children.
On April 3, 2023, Martinez spoke with Yazmin about taking the children, who
agreed to the placement. Yazmin described the children as “very good children” and
while she did not believe mother was physically abusive toward them, she had suspicions
about mother’s mental health. Mother had “popped up” at Yazmin’s home in the past.
Yazmin’s son had described some interactions with mother to Yazmin as well. On
one occasion, C.S. made a comment about a movie to the son, and mother told C.S. to
“stop being defiant.” On another occasion, the son witnessed mother going into C.S.’s
classroom to yell at him for leaving trash on the ground.
Yazmin also reported that mother had been repeatedly calling her on the phone
asking to see and speak with the children. Martinez called mother in the presence of
Yazmin and spoke with her about next steps. Mother asked if C.S. could remain with
Yazmin and the other children could be returned to her. She also repeatedly asked if there
was a possibility the children would be returned to her on April 4, 2023, after the team
decision making meeting. Mother indicated she was “fine” and did not need services.
On April 4, 2023, a team decision making meeting was held on behalf of the
children with several department staff, mother, Delbert, a maternal uncle, a maternal
cousin, and Yazmin in attendance. Mother repeated that she had a family friend take C.S.
6.
on April 2, 2023, because he was screaming, would not talk to Delbert on the phone and
put his fingers in his ears. Mother stated multiple times she wanted C.S. to “have
accountability” for his actions.
Mother said she does not spank her children and takes them to the library or to an
indoor sports center as a form of punishment. Mother said she wanted C.S. to know the
behavior was inappropriate and she performed a prayer circle with C.S. She said C.S.
apologized “with tears in his eyes.” Mother said she thought C.S. was trying to control
her, talks with a “strong tone” and asks questions such as “ ‘Are we going to the library,’
” or “ ‘Are we eating cereal.’ ” Mother then became tearful and said she was trying her
best and wanted the police to speak with C.S. about his behavior. Social worker
supervisor Greco-Fosdick said that mother looked overwhelmed and asked her if she felt
that way. Mother said she felt overwhelmed at the police station which is why she had
cried.
Delbert described mother’s situation as “complex” and that the discussion “was
barely hitting the tip of the iceberg.” He stated he feared for mother’s and the children’s
safety and wanted mother to receive “the help she needs.” He said several people had
asked mother to seek help, but she had not attempted to do so. Delbert also said father
confided in him before dying, and father had asked Delbert to apologize to C.S. on his
behalf for hurting C.S.
In response to Delbert’s statements mother stated, “ ‘God is on my side and
respects my liberty of consciousness.’ ” She said she felt like “she did not have a choice”
and said “ ‘I have the right to not believe in counseling. I haven’t said if I do or don’t.’ ”
She said she believed that whether she gets counseling or not should be confidential, and
that her father was “ ‘outing’ ” her and was using her past against her.
Mother stated that C.S. had previously attended counseling and indicated she
wanted to make an effort to get him back into counseling. The maternal uncle
commented that he wanted what was best for mother and the children, and wanted mother
7.
to understand that everyone was not out to get her. Mother stated she sensed the
department cared.
However, when social worker Leal-Monroy began explaining the voluntary family
maintenance and potential safety plan, mother became fixated on the notion that her
children were being removed from her care. She began to cry loudly and uncontrollably
and to pray aloud. She called various friends and told them her children were being
taken.
Greco-Fosdick explained that the primary concern was that when things didn’t go
mother’s way, she was unable to have a conversation or come to an agreement. However,
mother continued to cry uncontrollably. She said that people have “asked her for her
children” because they are so pretty, and that they specifically wanted her daughter. She
stated that her daughter was prettier than Yazmin’s daughter. She claimed the department
was upset they could not use “mind control” on her, and was telling her “ ‘[s]ee, see.’ ”
She stated that father was “dust in the ground,” that “people wanted her daughter,” and
that the department was “satanic.” Mother refused to sign any forms and left after being
provided paperwork and information for court. The children remained in Yazmin’s care.
On April 4, 2023, after the team decision making meeting, Martinez made a
follow-up phone call with Delbert, who stated he had more information he did not feel
comfortable sharing at the meeting. Delbert said that three or four years ago, mother
asked him to care for C.S. because mother believed C.S. was “satanic.” She did not
articulate why she felt that way. Delbert said that mother again told him that C.S. was
being “controlled by Satan” the prior week. He said that mother has been having C.S.
and S.H. stay with others for some time.
Delbert said that C.S. was in his care for six months, but mother called him “out of
the blue” and said she was driving up to San Francisco to get C.S. When he asked
mother why, she responded that as C.S.’s mother, it was her decision. She then moved
C.S. and S.H. into the home of an 80-year old couple from her church, noting that the
8.
wife had Alzheimer’s disease. Delbert said he did not believe mother was a fit parent,
and that she needed to submit to psychiatric help. He commented that she became
manipulative during meltdowns and was glad the department was involved.
Delbert said that when mother did not “get her way with men” she would threaten
to kill herself. She had a history of section 5150 holds since the onset of her relationship
with father, and when father tried to break up with her, she threatened to kill herself. He
stated the children had seen mother “take a crowbar to their father’s car.” He said he
believes mother’s behavior is partially a mental health issue and partially performance
acting. He said mother had an eating disorder since her teenage years and reported to
him four years before that she used to “cut herself.”
On April 4, 2023, Martinez also spoke with C.S. C.S. stated that on April 2, 2023,
mother had been on the phone with Delbert and tried to force C.S. to speak with him.
C.S. stated mother made him go into a small closet in his bedroom and she went inside
the closet with him. During that time, mother was yelling at him, and continued to call
Delbert. C.S. said he needed to use the bathroom, and mother said he needed to take
accountability for what he had done, and he needed to speak with Delbert. C.S. then
attempted to get on his bed in an effort to stop talking to Delbert. C.S. said he did not hit
or touch mother, but she got on his hands and pinned him down on his bed. Mother told
him, “ ‘You have a demon inside of you.’ ”
C.S. said that when he was eight years old, he did not want to listen to mother on
one occasion, and she told his siblings he had a demon in him. He said mother yells at
him a lot and tells him he is satanic. C.S said if he goes on social media, mother says he
is being satanic, and has also started calling his siblings satanic a few times. However,
she mostly yells at him. C.S. said “ ‘I feel like, what have I done? I’m just a normal kid.
I’m not doing any satanic stuff. I feel like, why are you doing this to me? I could not
even walk out of my room to use the restroom.’ ” C.S. stated he did not want to visit
mother.
9.
Prior Referrals
On March 28, 2012, the department received a call from a family therapist
reporting concerns for 8-month-old infant C.S. in mother and father’s care. Father had
called the therapist reporting that mother had cut her wrists. An ambulance responded
but did not take mother on a section 5150 hold because the cuts were superficial.
On December 27, 2019, the department received a call of suspected child abuse
against C.S. C.S. had told the reporting party that he was spanked with a belt, but did not
have any visible marks or bruises, and could not say the last time he was spanked. The
report was resolved as unfounded.
On April 8, 2021, the department received a report that C.S. was “beyond control.”
The reporting party stated that C.S. had thrown a skateboard at father, swung a hose and
hit him in the elbow, and thrown a bottle of oil at him. The reporting party stated that
C.S. had broken two windows in the home, and the reporting party had sustained a bruise
from C.S. The reporting party stated that C.S. harmed his siblings and mother and
everyone in the home had to tailor their behaviors to him. The report was resolved as
unfounded.
On April 9, 2021, the department received a report that father was afraid of one of
the children because the child was throwing things at him. The reporting party described
both mother and father as “ ‘crazy’ ” and said they should not be taking care of the
children, but could not give specifics. The report was evaluated out.
On June 24, 2021, the department received a report that mother had gone to
Arizona with the children. The reporting party stated mother left because father believed
C.S. to be possessed by a demon because of his behaviors and wanted C.S. placed in a
facility or foster care. The reporting party said mother also believes C.S. to be possessed
but did not want to place him in a facility. In Arizona, mother stayed with an aunt. A day
after arriving, C.S. “acted out” and law enforcement was called, after which C.S. was
placed in a facility.
10.
Family helped mother obtain stable housing, after which mother cut the family off.
Mother was able to get C.S. back from the facility, but shortly after, C.S. “acted out” and
mother kicked him out of the home in 119-degree weather. The reporting party called
child protective services over the incident. Mother then became ill and refused to seek
medical care, at which point father came to Arizona to care for her. The family returned
to California. The report was resolved as unfounded.
On June 30, 2021, the department received a report that mother expressed to her
brother she is suicidal, was cutting herself in front of the children and was overwhelmed
with the children because father was not helping. The report was resolved as unfounded.
On December 7, 2022, the department received two reports regarding mother. The
reporting party stated on July 16, 2022, mother had expressed in a group text “way too
much pressure” and stated, “ ‘the devil is trying to kill me.’ ” When mother spoke to a
family friend, she said something to the effect of, “ ‘I couldn’t commit suicide because of
the kids but if we were in the car and drove into a pond, we would all die together.’ ” The
family friend took mother’s two oldest children, who had been living with her since
July 2022. The reporting party had spoken with the family friend, who was concerned
about C.S. C.S. had made comments such as, “ ‘I wonder what would happen if I jump
off a bridge or a building’ ” and “ ‘I wonder what would happen to me if I hit my head
with this hammer.’ ” C.S. had also started chewing anything in sight, such as metal and
wood. The reports were evaluated out.
April 5, 2023 Detention Hearing
The juvenile court held an initial detention hearing on April 5, 2023. Mother
requested visitation and stated that she wants all of her children home as soon as possible.
The court found a prima facie case had been made the children fell within the provision
of section 300, that continuance of the children in the home of mother was contrary to the
children’s welfare and there was a substantial danger to the physical health of the children
or the children were suffering severe emotional damage. The court further found there
11.
were no reasonable means by which to protect the children’s health without removal, and
reasonable efforts had been made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal. The court
ordered supervised visitation a minimum of one time per week and ordered reunification
services for mother including a mental health evaluation and recommended treatment. A
combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing was scheduled for May 8, 2023.
Events Preceding the Jurisdiction and Disposition Hearing
Mother participated in a virtual visit with the children on April 12, 2023. The
children were communicative and discussed school and other activities with her. The
visit lasted the entire allotted time and ended with mother saying “ ‘love you forever’ ” to
each of the children.
Mother participated in an in-person supervised visit on April 25, 2023. The
children were initially excited to see mother and told her about going to the movies after
the visit and going to see the maternal grandparents for 10 days. They told mother about
their activities and said they had lately been eating meat.
C.S. then asked mother, “ ‘Why do you say it’s satanic to eat meat?’ ” Mother
responded, “ ‘I never said that.’ ” C.S., S.H., and E.H. then became frustrated with
mother and said she was lying, while mother continued to deny what the minors were
stating. C.S. then said that in the past, mother would hit him with a belt, would not let
them eat when they are hungry and would not let them in the kitchen. On one occasion,
C.S. said he snuck a cookie from the pantry and mother got on top of him and pulled the
cookie out of his mouth because he took it without asking. S.H. and E.H. said they
witnessed this happen, and mother denied it.
Mother sat quietly while the children questioned her about why she said
everything is satanic. C.S. then said, “ ‘I am saying everything so that the social worker
will document it.’ ” Mother said she loved the children and will love them forever. She
also said it is not good to lie and that the adults should not be manipulating them. C.S.
said on another occasion, mother pulled a corn chip out of his mouth because he did not
12.
ask for it, and E.H. said he saw that incident. Mother again denied doing that to C.S., and
the children called her a liar.
Mother requested to speak with the social worker outside. She said that she does
not like the minors visiting the maternal grandparents because she “ ‘cut ties’ ” with them
and they should not be “ ‘gossiping’ ” to her children. Mother said she is worried the care
provider and maternal grandparents are “ ‘manipulating’ ” her children, and commented
that her children are not happy. The social worker told mother it was her responsibility to
redirect them.
When mother returned to the room, C.S. and E.H. began telling her how they
wanted a “ ‘normal childhood.’ ” They expressed how they were having a good time
having a “normal childhood” with their care provider and maternal grandparents. C.S.
and S.H. said their care provider lets them in the kitchen, lets them eat whenever they are
hungry, and that they “aren’t hungry like they used to be when they were with her.” C.S.
and E.H. said “ ‘I want you to be a better mom.’ ” Mother responded that she loves them
both. Mother and children spent the rest of the visit playing a board game. The children
did not hug or kiss mother when the visit ended and pulled away when she tried to hug
them.
Mother attended another supervised visit on April 26, 2023. She read to and
played with the children, but they again did not want to hug or kiss her.
On May 19, 2023, Marcus Olivares, an investigator with Fresno Child Advocates,
spoke with the children. C.S. said his visits with mother go well. However, he did not
want to return to mother’s care. C.S. said that he did not think mother can care for him
because he has heard mother state to other people that she can care for his siblings, but
not him.
S.H. stated that his visits with mother are also going well, but he likewise does not
want to return to mother’s care. S.H. said he did not think mother could care for him
right now, because “ ‘she needs to go to more classes to learn how to feed us.’ ” E.H.
13.
said he did not want to return to mother’s care and did not think she could properly care
for him because “ ‘she lies a lot.’ ” S.O. did not wish to reside with mother, but would
like to reside with the maternal grandmother. When asked if S.O. believed mother could
properly care for her, she said she was not sure, and that “ ‘she would probably feed
me.’ ”
August 23, 2023 Jurisdiction and Disposition Hearing
The juvenile court held a combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing on
August 23, 2023. Mother testified, as did several witnesses on her behalf. Jamal Jones, a
licensed marriage and family therapist, had been working with mother for the past
nine months. Jones testified mother initially came to him with concerns of grief and loss
after losing her husband. They met biweekly with virtual visits, and had contact in
between sessions when mother needed support.
Jones described mother as loving her children, and he believed she understood her
responsibility to ensure their safety and well-being. He stated that the children were a
regular part of their conversations because they impacted her mental health and
well-being. Jones testified that mother never told him she did not want C.S. in the home,
even though when she came to Jones for treatment in November 2022, C.S. and S.H.
were living with members of mother’s church. Jones did not recall if mother explained
why the two children were not living with her and did not know the people they were
living with. Jones testified he believed mother continued to need therapy to deal with
issues such as emotional stability and her ability to cope with stress and life pressure.
Cheyenne Hernandez testified she lived with mother and the children from the
summer to the winter of 2021. Hernandez described mother as an attentive parent with a
close relationship with her children and did not see the children being put in danger or
suffering any injuries. Hernandez described mother would sometimes get overwhelmed
and would go into a room to take a moment and breathe. Hernandez gave examples of
behaviors which would result in mother becoming overwhelmed, including the children
14.
running around the house, raising their voices, climbing on furniture, or arguing with
one another. Hernandez also testified she saw mother go to several classes with her
husband, which Hernandez believed to be couples classes for parenting.
Mother testified that on April 2, 2023, she and the children were planning to go do
a “homeless ministry.” This involved preparing lunches and donating blankets to
community members in need. Around 7:00 a.m., mother woke up and C.S. “woke up
with a piercing scream.” Mother tried to get C.S.’s attention and tried to get him to
acknowledge that he shouldn’t scream. She was able to get him to agree that it was
wrong, but mother nonetheless called Delbert to speak with C.S. C.S. refused to speak
with Delbert, so mother called a family friend for help. According to mother, the friend
offered to take C.S. to the Sanctuary, and when mother saw that it was temporarily
closed, the friend said she knew some police officers who would talk with C.S.
On cross-examination, mother clarified that C.S. wasn’t acting out or screaming
but she still decided to send him to the police station because she “tried to implement
consequences.” She admitted telling C.S. that “if people are gossiping about me” and “if
people are trying to get you to go against me” that “it’s not right.” She testified she did
not remember making a statement that C.S. could not return home.
Mother also testified that she had “difficulties” with C.S. She had C.S. live with
Delbert for about five months, and later with a family friend. Mother claimed that when
C.S. lived with Delbert, she took him back because Delbert was going on a trip out of
state and wasn’t taking C.S. Mother decided to keep C.S. because she “just wanted to
take care of [her] child.” She then clarified that she sent C.S. to live with a family friend
for a few months afterward.
Leslie Rocha-Barraza, a social worker assigned to mother’s case, also testified.
She stated that mother was doing well with her mental health services and was
recommended a 52-week child abuse intervention program of which she had completed
seven sessions. Regarding visitation, Rocha-Barraza stated that the children reported
15.
they enjoyed structured, supervised time with mother but were not comfortable being
alone with mother during visits.
At a home visit on July 12, 2023, C.S. had told Rocha-Barraza that he did not want
to go home with mother because he was afraid she would do something “outlandish.”
C.S. explained he was afraid that mother would take them away or would hurt him and
his siblings. S.H. and S.O. did not respond when asked if they wanted to return home to
mother, and E.H. said he wanted to return when he was older.
Rocha-Barraza stated she was approached by the care provider and Delbert outside
of the courtroom, and informed that mother had come up to C.S. and told him, “don’t say
anything bad.” C.S. confirmed that is what mother said. On another occasion, C.S.
stated that mother tried to bribe him at one of the visits, and when visits were supervised
mother would whisper into the children’s ears.
Overall, Rocha-Barraza testified that the department believed there was substantial
danger to the children’s emotional well-being because the children had expressed that
mother lies to them, withholds food and limits what they eat, and doesn’t allow them to
do “normal kid things” like watch TV, play video games or do other things that they
enjoyed doing.
The juvenile court concluded:
“Based upon the reports that were presented to the Court and the
evidence that was presented to the Court including testimony and letters
from parties as well as the certificate that was provided to the Court this
afternoon, I will find that there is clear and convincing evidence that
continuance of the children in the home of [mother] is contrary to the
children’s welfare and there is or would be a substantial danger to the
physical health, safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of
the children if the children were returned home and there are no reasonable
means by which the children’s physical health can be protected without
removing the children from [mother’s] physical custody.
“That being said, I want to state that I agree … that [Jones’s]
testimony was credible. I believe that [mother] is making progress. I do
not expect perfection from parents because I agree with [mother] that there
16.
is no perfect parent. However, given what she’s been through, given what
the children have been through, and given [mother’s] testimony that all she
wanted was support, I believe that this can be a positive experience for
[mother] and that she can get the support that she needs from the
[department] and that can help her be a better parent in the future.
“I share the concerns of the [d]epartment of the well-being—the
emotional well-being of the children. I share the concerns of the
[d]epartment and mother kind of confirmed this in her testimony, there’s a
difference between gossip and the children telling the truth about what goes
on in their lives to professionals who are employed and who are—it is their
responsibility to make sure that children are safe. And if [mother] is
discouraging that I believe she’s going to regret that decision later.
“We have people … employed in these professions for a reason and
sometimes that’s because there are strangers that cause harm to children.
The children should not be [discouraged] from discussing their emotional,
physical, well-being with people who are obligated to look out for their best
interest.
“Something else that was noteworthy from [mother’s] testimony and
I may never know the answer to this question, what was wrong with [C.S.]
on [April 2] when he woke up screaming. Her testimony was that it was a
piercing scream so it would seem to this Court that prior to April 2[] there
was some emotional instability going on with [C.S.]
“I’m concerned about mother’s instability and I think that the
children are reflecting that. I hope that the orders of this Court today and
the participation by [mother] in services that are going to be asked of her
help her to address the instability, the emotional instability.”
The court found reasonable efforts had been made to prevent or eliminate the need
for removal of the children from the home and to make it possible for the children to
return to their home. The court found the extent of progress by mother toward alleviating
or militating the causes necessitating placement in foster care had been minimal. The
children were made dependents of the court pursuant to section 360, subdivision (d),
placed with their current care provider, and mother was ordered services, including a
mental health evaluation, and visitation.
17.
DISCUSSION
I. Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s Order Removing the
Children From Mother’s Custody
Mother argues the juvenile court failed to identify the “substantial danger” to the
children should they be returned to mother, therefore there was insufficient evidence to
support their removal pursuant to section 361, subdivision (c)(1). Mother further argues
she did not receive a mental health assessment or a professional diagnosis. Mother
concludes neither her mental health issues, nor the harm caused the children was
identified, therefore there was insufficient evidence to support the removal order. We
affirm. We find the juvenile court properly considered the specific facts of this case when
determining that there was a substantial danger to the children’s well-being if they were
returned to mother’s custody, there was substantial evidence to support such a ruling, and
mother need not have been diagnosed with a specific mental illness for the juvenile court
to make such a finding.
A. Legal Standard
Section 361, subdivision (c) prohibits the removal of a child from the physical
custody of his or her parent unless the juvenile court finds clear and convincing evidence
of certain enumerated circumstances. In relevant part, a child may be removed if “[t]here
is or would be a substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical
or emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned home, and there are no
reasonable means by which the minor’s physical health can be protected without
removing the minor from the minor’s parent[] .…” (§ 361, subd. (c)(1).)
A removal order is proper if it is based on proof of parental inability to provide
proper care for the minor and proof of a potential detriment to the minor if he or she
remains with the parent. (In re Jeannette S. (1979) 94 Cal.App.3d 52, 60.) The parent
need not be dangerous and the minor need not have been actually harmed before removal
18.
is appropriate. The focus of the statute is on averting harm to the child. (In re Jamie M.
(1982) 134 Cal.App.3d 530, 536 (Jamie M.).)
“ ‘[O]n appeal, the substantial evidence test is the appropriate standard of review.
Thus, in assessing this assignment of error, “the substantial evidence test applies to
determine the existence of the clear and convincing standard of proof .…” ’ ” (In re
Henry V. (2004) 119 Cal.App.4th 522, 529.) “In reviewing the sufficiency of the
evidence, our review requires that all reasonable inferences be given to support the
findings and orders of the juvenile court and the record must be viewed in the light most
favorable to those orders. [Citation.] Those findings and orders may not be disturbed if
they are supported by substantial evidence. [Citations.] … ‘Issues of fact and credibility
are questions [of fact] for the trial court, not [the appellate] court. [Citation.] “The rule is
clear that the power of the appellate courts begins and ends with a determination as to
whether there is any substantial evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted, which will
support the conclusion reached by the trier of fact.” ’ ” (In re Samkirtana S. (1990) 222
Cal.App.3d 1475, 1487.)
B. Analysis
Substantial Danger to the Children’s Emotional Health
The juvenile court found clear and convincing evidence that continuance of the
children in the home of mother would be a substantial danger to their physical health,
safety, protection, or physical and emotional well-being. The court relied on the
department’s reports and evidence presented at the hearing, including testimony and
letters, and the court’s findings are well supported by the record.
There was evidence presented mother suffered from mental health issues. Delbert
told social workers that mother used to cut herself, and C.S. said that at least on
one occasion she did so in front of him. C.S. expressed worry that she would cut herself
again. Mother, on multiple occasions, would yell at C.S. and call him, and occasionally
19.
his siblings, satanic. She told Delbert she believed C.S. was “controlled by Satan.” On
April 2, 2023, she told C.S. “ ‘You have a demon inside of you.’ ”
It is reasonable for the court to infer mother’s mental health issue manifested as
emotional instability. At the police station, when asked why C.S. could not return home,
mother began crying “hysterically” and fell to the ground. She began screaming that S.O.
was a female and would be molested. At the team decision making meeting on April 4,
2023, mother claimed that C.S. was trying to “control her” by talking to her with a
“strong tone” and asking questions. She became fixated on the notion that her children
were being removed, began to cry loudly and uncontrollably and to pray aloud, and
claimed that “people” wanted her daughter and that the department was satanic.
The children also told a social worker that mother would call many things
“satanic.” C.S. said mother told his siblings that there was a demon in him. They said
that mother would not only control what they ate but would go as far as to remove food
from their mouths if they ate it without her permission. On two occasions, mother pulled
food out of C.S.’s mouth—incidents witnessed by the other children. After living with
their care provider, the children also commented that they “aren’t hungry like they used
to be when they were with [mother].”
Mother tended to deny or diminish the children’s accounts and would be unable to
recall or would lie about her own behavior. When the children confronted her about her
withholding food and calling meat “satanic,” mother denied it, resulting in the children
becoming frustrated. Mother denied taking food out of the children’s mouths or denying
them food, and the children called her a liar. She then told a social worker that the
maternal grandparents should not be “ ‘gossiping’ ” to her children. Outside the
courtroom prior to testifying, she told C.S. that “if people are gossiping about [her] that
it’s not right.” C.S. in turn said that mother told him not to say anything bad.
Mother’s account of April 2, 2023, changed several times throughout the case. On
April 3, 2023, mother told social workers that she and the children were going to visit the
20.
children’s grandmother at the hospital, and C.S. was being defiant. He made a “piercing
scream noise” and mother ultimately called a friend to take C.S.4 When she testified,
mother claimed that she was getting the children ready to do a “homeless ministry” when
C.S. woke up screaming. She tried to calm him down, then called a friend who
recommended taking C.S. to the police station.
The friend, however, told officers on April 2, 2023, that mother had called her to
take C.S. “ ‘somewhere’ ” and did not specify where or for how long. Mother told the
friend that she could not have C.S. in the home. When officers spoke to mother on the
phone, she said that C.S. could not return home. Mother asked a social worker if C.S.
could stay with Yazmin and she could take the other three children home. At the
August 23, 2023 hearing, when asked if she remembered making a statement that C.S.
could not return home, mother answered “No.”
C.S. told a social worker that on April 2, 2023, after he screamed, mother forced
him to go into a small closet in his bedroom, where she yelled at him and tried to get him
to speak with Delbert on the phone. When he refused, mother pinned him down on his
bed, telling him he had a demon inside of him. At the police station on April 2, 2023,
mother could not provide a coherent explanation why she did not want C.S. home, other
than that C.S. “does not like her.”
Finally, mother sent C.S., then C.S. and S.H. to live with other people. She sent
C.S. to live with Delbert, then took C.S. back only to send him to live with friends from
mother’s church. Mother claimed she took C.S. back because Delbert was going on an
out-of-state vacation. However, Delbert told a social worker that mother called him “out
of the blue” and took C.S. because she was C.S’s mother and “it was her decision.” At
the August 23, 2023 hearing mother testified that she “just wanted to take care of [her]
4 C.S. in turn told the social worker that mother woke him up to clean, and he did
not want to, so he screamed.
21.
child.” However, she sent both C.S. and S.H. to live with the family friends from church
shortly afterward.
Many of these behaviors happened to the children or in their presence. It is not
unreasonable for the juvenile court to conclude that mother repeatedly calling C.S.
satanic, beginning to call the other children satanic and saying C.S. is possessed by a
demon, sending first C.S., then both C.S. and S.H. to live elsewhere, and engaging in
self-harm and emotionally unstable behaviors, would be substantially dangerous to the
children’s emotional well-being. Mother’s denial or minimization of these behaviors
compounds the harm. It is likewise not unreasonable for the court to conclude that
mother’s withholding food to the point of getting on top of C.S. and pulling food out of
his mouth, would be substantially dangerous to the children’s physical and emotional
well-being.
Finally, mother’s behaviors clearly had an effect on the children. None of the
children wanted to return to mother’s care. And while the children were not entitled to
decide where they would be placed,5 the children’s preference is evidence of actual harm
caused by mother’s behaviors. C.S. did not believe mother could care for him, and
believed mother would do something “outlandish” like hurt him and his siblings. S.H.
and S.O. were concerned mother did not know how to feed them. E.H. said he did not
believe mother could care for him because “ ‘she lies a lot.’ ”
Mother argues the juvenile court must specifically identify the “substantial
danger” or the actual harm the children would suffer if they were returned to her.
Section 361, subdivision (c) does not contain such a requirement. Section 361,
subdivision (e) requires the juvenile court to “state the facts on which the decision to
remove the minor is based.” However, the court is not required to identify the substantial
danger with the type of specificity mother is asserting. Nonetheless, the court stated that
5 In re John M. (2006) 141 Cal.App.4th 1564, 1570.
22.
it was concerned about the emotional well-being of the children, particularly because
mother was discouraging the children from speaking about their emotional and physical
well-being. The court also found there was emotional instability going on before April 2,
2023, because C.S. was waking up screaming. Finally, the court found the children were
reflecting mother’s instability.
Mother argues when a parent of a dependent child has a mental health issue, the
social worker must demonstrate with specificity how the minor has been or will be
harmed by the parents’ mental illness, relying on In re Kristin H. (1996) 46 Cal.App.4th
1635, 1657 (Kristin H.).
In Kristin H., the four-and-a-half-year-old minor was removed from mother’s
custody after mother was placed on a psychiatric hold due to taking unknown drugs
which made her sick. (Kristin H., supra, 46 Cal.App.4th at p. 1643.) The minor had
previously been found wandering alone on the street, and mother had reportedly been
heard telling the minor, “ ‘I can’t be bothered with you. I’m going to send you to the
shelter.’ ” (Ibid.) The minor expressed she did not want to return home. (Ibid.) Mother
had also previously attempted suicide by overdose, was taken to the hospital and the
minor was taken into protective custody, which resulted in mother entering into an
informal supervision agreement with the department of family and children’s services.
(Id. at p. 1644.)
The reunification process initially went well, with the minor and mother sharing a
strong bond and the minor stating she wanted to return to mother’s care. (Kristin H.,
supra, 46 Cal.App.4th at p. 1646.) However, when the jurisdiction hearing was delayed,
mother had an angry outburst and left the courtroom. (Ibid.) The social worker’s report
was largely positive but did note that mother coped poorly under stress and was unable to
refrain from inappropriate behaviors and angry outbursts. (Ibid.) After mother received
the report, she visited the minor and was unable to keep her anger under control. (Ibid.)
23.
Over the next several visits, she yelled at staff, refused to end visits to the point police
were called, and threatened to sue the facility. (Ibid.)
Mother was formally evaluated, and the evaluating doctor found mother angry and
agitated. (Kristin H., supra, 46 Cal.App.4th at p. 1647.) While mother had no overt
signs of depression or psychosis, the evaluating doctor noted he was “ ‘ “impressed by
her enormous denial and distortion of her situation” ’ ” and found mother tended to
externalize her problems, laying fault with the social workers or police, but not herself.
(Ibid.) The doctor found features of “ ‘ “borderline, and to some extent antisocial
personality disorders.” ’ ” (Ibid.) The doctor concluded, “ ‘ “[a]lthough she might be a
devoted and attentive mother much of the time, her potential for anxious, impulsive, and
neglectful behavior might be a hazard.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
At the final jurisdictional hearing, mother denied the need for medication and
stated she would not take any, expending “considerable energy assessing blame to others,
‘more concerned with proving she is right than with doing what she needs to do to
reunify with her child.’ ” (Kristin H., supra, 46 Cal.App.4th at p. 1648.) The juvenile
court sustained the petition and found clear and convincing evidence that returning the
minor to mother would be detrimental. (Ibid.)
As in this case, in Kristin H. the mother relied on the proposition that “[t]he social
worker must demonstrate with specificity how the minor has been or will be harmed by
the parents’ mental illness.…” (Jaime M., supra, 134 Cal.App.3d at p. 542.) The
appellate court disagreed. The court noted that in Jaime M., there was no evidence that
mother’s mental illness would adversely affect her children. In Kristin H., mother was a
substance abuser who made no effort to ensure her daughter was safe. (Kristin H., supra,
46 Cal.App.4th at p. 1657.) The mother was in denial about both her substance abuse and
the importance of treating her mental problems and refused to acknowledge her
responsibility or cooperate with professionals. (Id. at p. 1658.) The appellate court
concluded that although it was apparent from the record the mother and daughter were
24.
bonded, the evidence also supported the conclusion that the mother’s emotional
instability, substance abuse, and combative behavior presented a substantial risk of
danger to the minor. (Ibid.)
The juvenile court in Kristin H. found mother’s emotional instability and mental
health issues prevented her from ensuring the minor’s safety. Such a finding was
sufficiently “specific” to show how mother’s mental health issues posed a substantial
danger to the minor.
Comparatively, the social workers in this case thoroughly documented mother’s
behavior and its effect on the children in the detention, jurisdiction, and disposition
reports, as well as other supporting documents. Much like in Kristin H., mother in this
case also behaved in emotionally unstable ways which disregarded her children’s
well-being. Mother had a history of calling C.S. satanic and saying he had a demon
inside of him, as well as sending him away to live with others. These behaviors were
observed by the other children, and mother even began calling them satanic on occasion.
On April 2, 2023, she sent C.S. away with a friend and told the friend not to return C.S.
home. At the police station, and then at the team meeting, mother cried hysterically and
said bizarre things such as her children would be molested, and the department was
satanic. The children stated that mother would pull food out of their mouths. C.S.
witnessed mother self-harm and was afraid mother would either do so again or would
hurt him or his siblings. It is reasonable for the juvenile court to infer harm to at least the
children’s emotional well-being from mother’s emotionally unstable conduct. The record
in this case is replete with evidence to support the juvenile court’s finding, by clear and
convincing evidence, that returning the children to mother’s care would pose a substantial
danger to their physical or emotional well-being.
25.
Evidence of Mental Health Issues
Mother argues that she was never diagnosed with a mental illness, and never
participated in a mental health assessment. Relying on Jamie M., she concludes it is not
possible to determine how her mental health would adversely affect the children.
Jamie M. does not stand for the proposition that a parent’s mental health issues
must be formally diagnosed. To the contrary, Jamie M. clearly states that a diagnosis
alone is not enough to justify removal, and that “[h]arm to the child cannot be presumed
from the mere fact of mental illness of the parent and it is fallacious to assume the
children will somehow be “infected” by the parent.” (Jamie M., supra, 134 Cal.App.3d
at p. 540.) Instead, the juvenile court must “examine each factual situation to determine
what type of detriment might result” and “a juvenile court should examine the question of
parental custody from the child’s view point.” (Id. at p. 541.)
For a juvenile court to find jurisdiction pursuant to section 300,
subdivision (b)(1)(D), which grants jurisdiction when “[t]he child has suffered, or there is
a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of
… [t]he inability of the parent … to provide regular care for the child due to the parent’s
… mental illness,” the juvenile court must find the existence of mental illness. That is
because “the circumstances under which the juvenile court is authorized to take
jurisdiction of a child are narrowly defined.” (In re Nicholas B. (2001) 88 Cal.App.4th
1126, 1134.)
Section 361, subdivision (c)(1) has no such limitation once jurisdiction is
established. A juvenile court may remove a child from the physical custody of a parent
when there is substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection or physical or
emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned home. (§ 361,
subd. (c)(1).) Whether that danger arises from a parent’s diagnosed (or undiagnosed)
mental illness is relevant only insofar as it relates to the specific factual situation in each
individual case. (Jamie M., supra, 134 Cal.App.3d at p. 541.)
26.
In this case, mother was not formally diagnosed with a mental illness. However,
this does not negate mother’s documented behaviors and the effect those behaviors had
on the children. The juvenile court thoroughly reviewed the record and based its ruling
not on the fact that mother may be suffering from mental health issues, but rather on
mother’s emotionally unstable behaviors and her attempts to prevent the children from
speaking about their emotional and physical well-being. The record reflects substantial
evidence of substantial danger to the children’s physical health, safety, protection or
physical or emotional well-being if they were to be returned to mother’s custody.
II. Sufficient Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s Finding There Were No
Reasonable Means to Prevent or Eliminate the Need for Removal
Mother argues there was no evidence that any reasonable alternatives to removal
were considered and rejected or tried and failed. Mother further argues there was
insufficient evidence that reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need
for removal. We find reasonable efforts were made and rejected by mother, and affirm.
Section 361, subdivision (e) states, “[t]he court shall make a determination as to
whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent or to eliminate the need for removal of
the minor from his or her home” and “that these efforts have proved unsuccessful. The
court shall state the facts on which the decision to remove the minor is based.”
“To aid the court in determining whether ‘reasonable means’ exist for protecting
the children, short of removing them from their home, the California Rules of Court
require [the department] to submit a social study which ‘must include’ among other
things: ‘A discussion of the reasonable efforts made to prevent or eliminate removal.’ ”
(In re Ashly F. (2014) 225 Cal.App.4th 803, 809.)
Mother argues there is no evidence in the record that reasonable alternatives to
removal were considered or tried. We disagree. The record reflects that on April 4, 2023,
mother participated in a team decision making meeting on behalf of the children, with
several department staff, several of mother’s family members including Delbert, and the
27.
current care provider Yazmin in attendance. Delbert expressed concern for mother and
wanted her to receive the help she needed, to which mother responded that she had the
right not to believe in counseling, and whether she received counseling should be
confidential.
Department staff then attempted to explain voluntary family maintenance and a
potential safety plan to mother. In response, mother became fixated on the notion that her
children were being removed from her care and began crying uncontrollably and praying
out loud. Attempts to calm her failed, and mother concluded the meeting by claiming
that people wanted her daughter, and that the department was trying to use mind control
on her and was “satanic.” She declined a parent partner referral, would not sign the
language or Indian Child Welfare Act forms, and left. As a result, the department
determined that voluntary family maintenance services were not appropriate and a safety
plan could not be made.
Contrary to mother’s assertion, this is not a case where the department failed to
make a reasonable effort to prevent the children’s removal. The department was prepared
to discuss voluntary family maintenance and a safety plan which would have allowed the
children to remain in mother’s home. In response, mother began crying uncontrollably,
refused to participate in the planning and made outlandish statements and accusations
about the department.
Likewise, the record reflects that throughout the proceedings in this case mother
minimized or refused to acknowledge the behaviors that led to the children’s removal.
She testified that she did not remember saying that C.S. could not return home on April 2,
2023, and her story about the events of that day was inconsistent throughout the
development of this case. On August 23, 2023, she testified that it wasn’t even her idea
to remove C.S. from the home, and that the family friend she called recommended it.
The friend, in turn, told officers that mother called her to take C.S. “ ‘somewhere’ ” and
not return him home. Mother refused the children’s allegations that she would call things
28.
satanic, limit their food, or take food from them. She minimized telling C.S. “not to say
bad things” and telling him that gossiping is “not right.”
Mother offers that unannounced visits, in-home support, or family therapy would
have been sufficient. Given mother’s extreme reaction to the department’s attempts to
develop a voluntary family maintenance and safety plan, and mother’s persistent denial of
her problematic behaviors, it is unclear how such services would prevent the harm which
led to the children’s removal. The department’s efforts need only be reasonable. It is
unclear what reasonable efforts the department could conceive to prevent the children
from harm, other than removal. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s finding
that reasonable efforts were made to prevent or to eliminate the need for removal of the
children and that these efforts had proven unsuccessful.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s disposition order is affirmed.
29.
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.