In re A.E. CA4/1

CourtListener 10015309Calctapp26.07.2024

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 7/26/24 In re A.E. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In re A.E., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
D083348
SAN DIEGO COUNTY HEALTH
AND HUMAN SERVICES
AGENCY, (Super. Ct. No. EJ004871)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

Q.E.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Mark T. Cumba, Judge. Affirmed.

Megan Turkat Schirn, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Claudia G. Silva, County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief Deputy
County Counsel, and Kristen M. Ojeil, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
INTRODUCTION
Q.E. (Father) appeals from the juvenile court’s jurisdictional order

under Welfare and Institutions Code1 section 300, subdivision (a), which
resulted in the removal of six-year-old A.E. from his custody and exit orders
granting full legal and physical custody to C.M. (Mother). Father contends
insufficient evidence supports the court’s finding he inflicted the injuries
described in the dependency petition, and that there was no substantial risk
of future harm to A.E. Pointing to inconsistencies in A.E.’s statements and
other evidence, Father argues someone else inflicted the injuries while A.E.

was in Mother’s custody. We affirm.2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I.
Dependency Petition and Detention
A.E. was born in August 2017. Father entered his life two years later
following the entry of a paternity judgment in 2019. A.E. then spent four
nights per week with Father at paternal grandparents’ home and three
nights per week with Mother and his maternal half-brother at Mother’s
home. Relevant here, A.E. was in Father’s custody from Friday afternoon,

April 28, 20233 until Father dropped him off at school on Tuesday morning,

1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code unless otherwise indicated.

2 We agree with the parties that Father’s appeal is not rendered moot by
the juvenile court’s termination of jurisdiction. (See In re D.P. (2023) 14
Cal.5th 266, 285–287; see also § 362.4 [custody and visitation orders issued
by the juvenile court on its own motion remain in effect until modified or
terminated by a subsequent order of the superior court].)

3 All further dates refer to 2023 unless noted otherwise.

2
May 2. Mother picked him up from school that afternoon, and A.E. was
scheduled to return to Father’s custody after school on Friday, May 5.
On Wednesday, May 3, the Child Abuse Hotline received a report that
then five-year-old A.E. had disclosed Father gave him “whoppings” with a
belt that left marks, including a small healing scab on his hand observed by
the reporter. According to the Agency’s detention report, “[t]here was an
incident on Monday [May 1] in which the father hit [A.E.] with a belt and left
belt marks on [A.E.’s] thigh, butt, and hand. The mother observed the marks
on Tuesday [May 2] and pictures were taken.”
During his weekly therapy session on May 3, A.E. disclosed Father
“whopped” him and showed the therapist a resulting scar on his wrist. When
the therapist asked to hear more, A.E. responded, “You don’t want to hear
about that” and would only say the “whooping[ ]s” happened at Father’s
house. Mother was not present when A.E. made the disclosure. When the
therapist spoke with her at the end of the session, Mother said she was aware
of A.E.’s injuries and had taken photographs. She had taken A.E. to see a
doctor for suspected abuse, but according to her, “nothing happen[ed]” as a
result of her report. The therapist also reached out to Father, who did not
respond to her calls.
On May 4, a social worker interviewed A.E. at school. A.E. refused to
speak with the social worker until he called Mother, who encouraged him to
do so while on speakerphone. A.E. allowed the social worker to take
photographs of injuries on his left inside wrist and his back, but he did not
want to show them injuries he had on other parts of his body. When the
worker asked in which house the injuries occurred, he replied, “You know.”
The social worker also interviewed Mother on May 4. After she picked
A.E. up from school on May 2, Mother noticed he had red marks on his

3
buttocks and legs, and A.E. told her, “[M]y dad hit me with a belt.” Mother
took photographs at 3:37 p.m. on May 2 showing red markings on A.E.’s bare
buttocks, back, and thighs.
Mother denied using physical discipline in her home and suspected
A.E. was being physically abused while he was in Father’s care. She had
taken A.E. to the emergency room on previous occasions but was told it was
“not abuse,” and she would have to return A.E. to Father. A.E. was
scheduled to return to Father’s custody on May 5, but Mother agreed to seek
a temporary restraining order and take A.E. to Chadwick Center for Children
and Families at Rady Children’s Hospital (Chadwick) for a physical abuse
exam.
On May 5, child abuse expert Dr. Natalie Laub examined A.E. and
observed he was “covered in marks.” She specifically noted semi-circular
hyperpigmented marks on his right thigh, hyperpigmented loop marks on his
left thigh and interior left wrist, an amorphous hyperpigmented area on his
left buttock, amorphous hyperpigmented marks on his lower back, and a
small, scabbed area near the thumb of his left hand. Dr. Laub concluded the
marks were “diagnostic of physical abuse” and also noted Mother had brought
A.E. to Chadwick on four prior occasions with concerns of abuse by Father,
but a forensic interview had not been conducted despite two prior
recommendations. Expressing her “significant concerns for [A.E.’s] safety
and wellbeing,” Dr. Laub again recommended a forensic interview.
On May 8, A.E. underwent a forensic interview at Chadwick.
According to the forensic interviewer’s report, A.E. disclosed “something ha[d]
happened” at Father’s house and that he gets “whoopings” with a “[b]lack belt
and a white charger.” He said it hurts when he gets “whoopings,” but he “did
not provide further details regarding marks found on his body during the

4
medical exam.” When the interviewer asked him what happened the last
time he saw Father, A.E. said Father gave him a “whooping” on his
“bottom/butt.”
The Agency’s detention report includes additional details of the May 8
forensic interview: “[A.E.] said the dad keeps the belt in his closet. [A.E.]
denied anyone else using physical discipline. When asked what part of his
body, [A.E.] said, ‘I don’t know.’ He said he could not remember then said
‘you don’t want to know.’ [A.E.] denied receiving any marks or bruises when
his father whoops him. When [the forensic interviewer] asked [A.E.] about
the injuries seen by the doctor during the medical exam, [A.E.] said, ‘You
don’t want to know.’ [A.E.] did not disclose how he received the recent
markings on his body. He did not want to show the markings to the
interview[er]. [A.E.] said he feels ‘angry’ when he is whopped. He said when
he is whopped; he does not tell his dad his feelings. When asked if he felt
safe with his dad, [A.E.] said ‘no’ but he feels safe with his mom.”
On May 8, Mother and the social worker created a safety plan whereby
Mother would not allow A.E. to return to Father’s custody and would seek a
restraining order and an emergency custody order from the family court.
After multiple, unsuccessful attempts to reach Father, the social
worker interviewed him on May 26. He denied using physical discipline and
inflicting the marks observed on A.E. Father asserted Mother had “a history
of claiming he is physically abusing [A.E.] when it is actually occurring at her
home,” and he suspected Mother’s boyfriend was abusing A.E. Father had
begun taking videos of A.E. to document that he returned A.E. to Mother’s
custody without any “new” marks or bruises.
Father showed the social worker two videos. The first video, time
stamped at 7:18 p.m. on April 28, showed a mark on A.E.’s left wrist and

5
markings on his inner thighs. The second video, time stamped at 8:10 a.m.
on May 2, showed A.E. slowly turning around while completely naked to
reveal a marking on A.E.’s left wrist, which Father noted had been there for a
while and had also appeared in his April 28 video. According to Father, A.E.
arrived at school at 8:45 a.m. on May 2 and had he “whopped” him that
morning, the marks would have shown up in his video, A.E. would have
complained while at school, or the school staff would have noticed something
was wrong.
On June 12, Father contacted the social worker and asserted Mother’s
boyfriend J.E., whom A.E. also referred to as “dad,” was the one hurting A.E.
On June 30, the social worker interviewed A.E.’s paternal grandfather.
He denied that Father or anyone else in their home used physical discipline.
He shared Father’s concerns that A.E. was being abused at Mother’s home
and reported Mother had “called CPS on [Father] so many times.” To “keep
the mother from being allowed to railroad the father in Family Court and get
full custody of [A.E.],” they perform a complete body check when A.E. arrives
and leaves their home and “document” it with photographs and videos.
That same day, the social worker made an unannounced visit to
Mother’s home and performed a full body check of A.E., which did not reveal
any marks or bruises. A.E.’s older half-brother, A.M., denied Mother had a
boyfriend or a male friend who came over and denied anyone else was living
in the home. Mother reported she had not had any contact with J.E. since
2020, and the worker did not observe any adult male clothing or personal
grooming items in the home. The worker left two voicemail messages for
J.E., but he did not respond.
The social worker also spoke with Dr. Laub on June 30. Dr. Laub
explained the acute markings she had observed on May 5 could show up

6
within minutes of A.E. being injured and up to one hour later. She further
explained the marks would have shown up on the video if A.E. had been
disciplined before the video was taken, or the injuries could have been
inflicted after the video was taken or when A.E. was home with Mother. Dr.
Laub also remarked, “[I]t is important to remember that [A.E.] has been
consistently stating that his father whoops him with a belt and a charger
cord.”
On July 3, the San Diego Health and Human Services Agency (Agency)
filed a dependency petition pursuant to section 300, subdivision (a) alleging:
“On or about May 5, 2023, the child was diagnosed with having multiple
hyperpigmented marks throughout his body, including on his thighs, wrist
and hand which the child abuse expert has deemed are diagnostic of physical
abuse. The child has provided disclosures consistent with the perpetrator of
such abuse being [Father] whom the child states has ‘whopped’ him with a
belt and phone charger. [Father] denies the allegations and the child’s
mother has been unable to protect the child despite her efforts. Therefore,
court intervention is required as there is substantial risk that the child will
continue to suffer serious physical harm inflicted non-accidentally.” On July
5, the juvenile court found the Agency made a prima facie showing the
allegations were true and detained A.E. with Mother and ordered liberal,
supervised visitation with Father.
II.
Contested Jurisdiction/Disposition Hearing
The contested jurisdiction/disposition hearing was held on October 27.
The juvenile court received into evidence, over Father’s objections, the
Agency’s various reports. Before addressing Father’s testimony, we

7
summarize additional evidence gathered by the Agency in advance of the
hearing.
The Agency interviewed A.E. in July, August, September, and October.
A.E. reported feeling safe at Mother’s house, but he did not feel safe at
Father’s house. When the social worker asked A.E. about his visits with
Father, he said he felt “fun.”
When a newly assigned social worker asked A.E. about his “owwies” in
July, he first said he didn’t have any, and then said he did but did not know
how he got them. When the worker asked him what happens when he is in
trouble, he responded, “[D]ad does everything to me” and then said, “I do not
know, maybe owwies I guess, yeah, yeah.” Later in the interview, A.E.
denied that either Mother or Father spanked him and denied having any
“owwies” in the past.
In August and October, A.E. again denied Mother spanked him, but
during his September interview, he disclosed Mother used to give him
“whoopings” when he had “bad days” in kindergarten. He explained Mother
only used her open hand and never left a mark or a bruise and insisted, “She
doesn’t do it anymore. Only in kindergarten.” When the social worker
reached out to A.E.’s therapist after this disclosure, she said A.E. had
disclosed Mother used “whoopings” in the past, but he described them as
“yelling” and “never said anything about spankings.”
Father maintained Mother’s boyfriend J.E. inflicted the marks
observed on A.E. and continued to refer to him as “the other father” although
A.E. had denied calling anyone other than Father “dad, daddy, papa, pop, or
father.” Father reported A.E. had previously told him J.E. punched him in
the face and choked him, similar to alleged abuse inflicted on A.E.’s older
brother, and, more recently, A.E. disclosed J.E. punched him in the face,

8
leaving a mark on his eye that Father observed on June 9.4 A.E. had also
told Father that both J.E. and Mother “whooped” him because he clogged up
the toilet.
A.E.’s paternal grandparents also continued to deny that A.E. was
abused in their home, and they asserted Mother was lying and coaching A.E.
to say things that were not true. The grandfather reported that A.E. had
disclosed that both Mother and J.E. “whooped” him, and Mother had also
admitted to spanking A.E.
In its assessments, the Agency noted Father “made minimal to no effort
to visit with the [A.E.]” and “ha[d] not seen the child since the initial
investigation.” Mother, on the other hand, had demonstrated her ability to
meet A.E.’s needs. The Agency had not seen any evidence of Mother coaching
A.E. It also noted A.E.’s story had been “generally consistent as to the
‘whoopings’ ” and the child abuse expert had provided an explanation for the
marks and bruises not appearing on Father’s video. During the months that
A.E. was solely in Mother’s care, A.E. had not reported any physical
discipline and had not sustained any new concerning marks or injuries.
Multiple collateral contacts, including A.E.’s therapist, teacher, school
counselor, and babysitter, expressed having no concerns about Mother.

4 The Agency’s reports do not reflect a communication from Father about
his observation of a fading mark on A.E.’s eye on June 9, but the July 5
detention report refers to a mark on the A.E.’s eye relative to a 2022
“inconclusive” child welfare services referral alleging physical abuse by
Father. Additional referral history involving physical abuse of A.E. includes
an unfounded allegation of physical abuse by an unknown perpetrator in
2019, an inconclusive referral for alleged physical abuse of the A.E. and his
sibling by J.E. in 2020, and two additional allegations of physical abuse by
Father in 2022 that were inconclusive or evaluated out.

9
Mother continued to take A.E. to weekly therapy sessions, which the Agency
observed would subject her to ongoing community oversight.
The Agency recommended the juvenile court find the allegations in the
petition true and find A.E. to be a dependent child under section 300 (a). It
also recommended removal of A.E. from Father’s custody, termination of
juvenile court jurisdiction with custody orders awarding Mother full custody
and supervised contact with Father until Father could adequately address
the protective issues.
At the hearing, Father testified on his own behalf. Father had
observed “marks, bruises, scars, welt marks, et cetera” in the past, but
Mother “would never seek . . . medical care.” He also testified A.E. would
come over to his house hungry and dressed in dirty clothes. Father denied
inflicting the alleged injuries and maintained the “main perpetrator” was
unknown. He asserted the Agency’s reports regarding markings from a belt
and a charger were “unfounded” and had provided the social worker with
“document[ation] that [A.E.] . . . came over with certain marks . . . on Friday,
[April 28].”
The juvenile court found the allegations in the dependency petition true
by a preponderance of the evidence and declared A.E. to be a dependent of
the court under section 300, subdivision (a). The court further found, by clear
and convincing evidence, there was a danger to A.E.’s physical health or
emotional well-being and his removal from Father was appropriate under
section 361, subdivision (c)(1). In making its ruling, the court explained it
relied on the Agency’s reports, including the reports from the medical
providers and A.E.’s statements. It recognized A.E. was six years old and
that Father had raised apparent inconsistencies in A.E.’s statements but
concluded A.E.’s statements “went back to the minor indicating that he was

10
hit or struck by the father or whooped by the father, or at least in one quote,
[A.E.] said, ‘My dad hit me with the belt.’ ”
As to its dispositional order, the juvenile court noted there had been no
evidence of injuries or bruising since A.E. had been placed with Mother and
out of Father’s care. The court signed the proposed custody and visitation
order granting Mother full legal and physical custody of A.E. and permitting
supervised visitation with Father, adopted the Agency’s remaining
recommendations, and terminated the juvenile court’s jurisdiction. (See
§ 362.4.)
DISCUSSION
Section 300, subdivision (a), authorizes the juvenile court to assert
dependency jurisdiction when, “[t]he child has suffered, or there is a
substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted
nonaccidentally upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian.” Sitting as
the trier of fact, the court asserts dependency jurisdiction over a child if it
finds the allegations of harm true by a preponderance of the evidence
(§§ 300, 355).
The juvenile court’s orders are presumed to be correct, and it is
appellant’s burden on appeal to affirmatively show error. (See In re
J.F. (2019) 39 Cal.App.5th 70, 79.) “In reviewing the jurisdictional findings
and the disposition, we look to see if substantial evidence, contradicted or
uncontradicted, supports them. In making this determination, we draw all
reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the findings and orders of
the dependency court [and] review the record in the light most favorable to
the court’s determinations.” (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 633 [cleaned
up].)

11
“We do not reweigh the evidence or exercise independent judgment, but
merely determine if there are sufficient facts to support the findings of the
trial court.” (In re L.O. (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 227, 238.) We defer to the
juvenile court’s credibility determinations because the juvenile court, as the
trier of fact, “is in a superior position to observe the demeanor of witnesses.”
(In re George T. (2004) 33 Cal.4th 620, 634.) Any conflicts in the evidence
must be resolved in favor of the prevailing party, and where there is more
than one inference which can reasonably be deduced from the facts, the
appellate court is without power to substitute its deductions for those of the
trier of fact. (In re Jason L. (1990) 222 Cal.App.3d 1206, 1214.) If a juvenile
court’s finding is supported by substantial evidence, we must affirm, even if
other evidence supports a contrary finding. (Ibid.) “ ‘The ultimate test is
whether it is reasonable for a trier of fact to make the ruling in question in
light of the whole record.’ ” (In re Savannah M. (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 1387,
1394, abrogated on other grounds in In re R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 628.)
Applying these well settled principles, we conclude substantial evidence
supports the juvenile court’s jurisdictional order. Father has not met his
burden on appeal to show there is no evidence that is “ ‘reasonable, credible,
and of solid value’ ” from which a reasonable trier of fact could find that
Father inflicted the injuries on A.E. (In re Sheila B. (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th
187, 199.)
Unlike criminal proceedings, where the burden of proof is beyond a
reasonable doubt and “ ‘where establishing the identity of the perpetrator is
paramount, the purpose of dependency proceedings [is] to fashion appropriate
orders in the best interests of the child’ . . . [and] “to provide maximum safety
and protection” for currently abused and neglected children and to ensure the
safety of children at risk of harm.” (In re A.S. (2011) 202 Cal.App.4th 237,

12
245–246, overruled in part on other grounds in In re Conservatorship of O.B.
(2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1010, fn. 7.) In finding the allegations of the petition
true by a preponderance of the evidence, the juvenile court credited A.E.’s
statements that Father had “whooped” him with a “belt” and the statements
of the medical providers, as it was entitled to do. On appeal, Father does not
challenge the juvenile court’s admission of A.E.’s statements (see § 355
[hearsay exception for statements made by a child under the age of 12]) and
the statements of the medical providers stand uncontroverted.
Father contends “A.E. never stated that [F]ather caused the injuries
during his medical examination,” “[t]here was ample evidence that both
[M]other and [F]ather had given the child ‘whoopings’,” and claims his video
definitively established A.E. had no visible injuries at the end of [his] May 2,
2023 visit [with Father].” Father’s arguments overlook the governing
standard of review. On appeal, “we must accept the evidence most favorable
to the order as true and discard the unfavorable evidence as not having
sufficient verity to be accepted by the trier of fact.” (In re Casey D. (1999) 70
Cal.App.4th 38, 53, overruled on other grounds in In re Caden C. (2021) 11
Cal.5th 614, 636, fn. 5.) “[I]t is not our function to reweigh the evidence,
reappraise the credibility of witnesses or redetermine factual conflicts.” (In
re Frederick (1979) 96 Cal.App.3d 353, 367.) Father improperly asks us to do
just that by highlighting other evidence in the Agency’s reports he believes is
exculpatory while disregarding the evidence that supports the juvenile court’s
order.
Father acknowledges A.E. had disclosed he gave him “whoopings” with
a “belt” and “white phone charger” during his forensic interview on May 8,
but points to portions of the Agency’s summary of the interview stating A.E.
“did not know what part of his body was hit,” “did not disclose how he

13
received the recent markings on his body,” and “denied receiving any marks
or bruises when his father whoops him.” Father ignores the forensic
interviewer’s statement that A.E. “did not provide further details regarding
marks found on his body during the medical exam” (italics added), and A.E.’s
specific statement that he “got a ‘whopping’ on his ‘bottom/butt’ from his
father” the last time he saw him. Father similarly ignores A.E.’s May 3
disclosure to his therapist that he was “whooped” in Father’s home and the
May 3 referral to the Child Abuse Hotline in which A.E. reported “[F]ather
would hit him with a belt and . . . leave marks.” Instead, Father points to
A.E.’s disclosure to the social worker in September that he also received
“whoopings” from Mother and disregards A.E.’s explanation that Mother had
only spanked him with an open hand and never left a mark or a bruise.
Father also references his parents’ statements that he did not
physically abuse A.E. and two child welfare referrals in 2018, before he was
involved in A.E.’s life, that involved allegations of physical abuse of A.E.’s
older half-brother by Mother to support his theory that Mother or someone
else inflicted the injuries described in the dependency petition.
The juvenile court was free to assign value and weight to paternal
grandparents’ statements (see In re Frederick, supra, 96 Cal.App.3d at
p. 367), and to the extent the referrals involved indirect risk to A.E. based on
the allegations of physical abuse of his sibling, they were “unfounded” or
“evaluated out.” Unsubstantiated allegations from 2018 cannot serve to
refute the substantial evidence supporting the juvenile court’s finding that
Father physically abused A.E. approximately five years later.
In finding the allegations in the dependency petition true, the juvenile
court properly considered and relied on A.E.’s statements that Father hit him
with a belt. “Courts evaluating abuse allegations must keep in mind that a

14
child’s verbal and cognitive limitations may prevent [him] from providing an
account of [his] abuse that is as coherent and consistent as we might expect
from an adult. A child’s account may reflect uncertainty, and may even
contain some contradictions, and nevertheless warrant the court’s trust.” (In
re I.C. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 869, 896; see also In re Marriage of Mix (1975) 14
Cal.3d 604, 614 [the testimony of a single witness, if believed by the
factfinder, may constitute substantial evidence].)
The juvenile court also relied on the uncontroverted evidence from the
medical providers, which Father attempts to minimize. He insists the video
he took on the morning of May 2 at 8:10 a.m. establishes A.E. had no injuries
before he was dropped off at school, and he misstates the record by claiming
“[t]he child abuse expert agreed that the acute injuries she saw on [A.E.]
would have shown up in father’s video if inflicted by father.” Dr. Laub’s
actual opinion was that “the acute markings seen on [A.E.] could show up
within minutes of being injured up to one hour later.” She explained the
markings would have shown up in Father’s video “if [A.E.] was disciplined
prior [to Father taking] the video” and further clarified the injuries could have
been inflicted “after the video was taken or when [A.E.] was home with the
mother.” (Italics added.) The juvenile court could properly rely on Dr. Laub’s
statements to infer that Father inflicted the injuries after taking the video at
8:10 a.m. but before dropping A.E. off at school at 8:45 a.m., and on appeal,
we draw all reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the juvenile
court’s findings and order. (See In re R.T., supra, 3 Cal.5th at p. 633.)
Father’s attempt to buttress his argument by noting the only injury
observed by the referral reporter was a small healing scab on May 3 is
similarly unavailing. The record does not suggest the referral reporter
performed a fully body check or visualized other areas of A.E.’s body,

15
including his thighs, buttocks, and lower back that bore the additional
markings observed by Dr. Laub during the physical abuse exam on May 5.
Furthermore, although Father acknowledges “Mother claimed she first saw
the marks on [May 2],” he ignores that Mother showed the social worker
photographs she had taken of A.E.’s injuries at 3:37 p.m. on May 2 showing
red markings on A.E.’s bare buttocks, back, and thighs.
Father’s reliance on In re G.Z. (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 857 is also
misplaced. The Court of Appeal in that case reversed the jurisdictional
findings because the medical expert had concluded the child’s subdural
hematomas may or may not have been caused by non-accidental trauma. The
court explained “[i]t is not [the parent’s] burden . . . to exclude nonaccidental
inflicted trauma as a possible cause of G.Z.’s injuries. It is [the Agency’s]
burden to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that nonaccidental
trauma was the cause of injury.” (Id. at p. 878.) Unlike In re G.Z., Dr. Laub
unequivocally concluded the markings observed on A.E. were “diagnostic of
physical abuse.”
Lastly, Father argues A.E. was no longer at risk of future harm at the
time of the contested jurisdictional/disposition hearing. The assertion of
dependency jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (a), is appropriate
when “[t]he child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child
will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally upon the child by
the child’s parent.” (Italics added.) The juvenile court need not make an
express finding of substantial risk of future harm; it’s finding that A.E. had
suffered serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally by Father is
sufficient to support its jurisdictional order. (See In re David H. (2008) 165
Cal.App.4th 1626, 1644.) Furthermore, the court observed that A.E. did not
sustain any injuries or bruising indicative of physical abuse while in Mother’s

16
sole care. (See In re James D. (1981) 116 Cal.App.3d 810, 813 [substantial
evidence also includes circumstantial evidence and any reasonable inferences
drawn from that evidence].)
In sum, we conclude there is substantial evidence in the record to
support the juvenile court’s assertion of jurisdiction over A.E. pursuant to
section 300, subdivision (a).
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s October 27, 2023 order is affirmed.

DO, J.

WE CONCUR:

IRION, Acting P. J.

CASTILLO, J.

17

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.