CourtListener 10004450•In re M.R. CA4/3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 7/15/24 In re M.R. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re M.R., et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G063458
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 23DP0858,
v. 23DP0859)
K.R., et al., OPINION
Defendants and Appellants.
Appeal from orders of the Superior Court of Orange County, Julie
Anne Swain, Judge. Affirmed.
Michelle D. Peña, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant K.R.
Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant J.R.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez, Supervising
Deputy, and Aurelio Torre, Senior Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
* * *
K.R. (Mother) and J.R. (Father) separately appeal from the
Orange County Juvenile Court’s jurisdictional and dispositional orders
declaring their two children, M.R. (13 years old) and Mc.R. (12 years old),
dependents of the juvenile court and removing them from parental custody.
The court found the children came within its jurisdiction under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (b)(1)1, and removed the children
from the parents’ care.
Both Mother and Father contend the court’s jurisdictional order
must be reversed because there was insufficient evidence of a substantial risk
to the children. They also argue there was insufficient evidence to support
the dispositional order removing the children from their custody. We
conclude the court’s findings were supported by substantial evidence and
therefore affirm.
1
All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
2
FACTS
3
On August 8, 2023, Mother, Father, M.R., and Mc.R. were living
in an RV parked temporarily outside the maternal grandfather’s home.
Orange County Sheriff Department deputies and Orange County Fire
Authority paramedics were called after Mother had difficulty breathing and
lapsed into unconsciousness. Upon arrival, the paramedics administered
multiple doses of Narcan, a drug which reverses the effects of opioid overdose.
Mother then regained consciousness and was transported to the hospital.
Although Father indicated to the sheriff’s deputies the Mother did not use
drugs, the deputies at the scene suspected a fentanyl overdose.
Father and Mc.R. were outside of the RV with Mother when the
sheriff’s deputies and paramedics arrived. One of the sheriff’s deputies
contacted M.R., who indicated he was “stuck” inside the RV and “needed
help” as he was “trapped behind a ‘pop-out’ section of the RV.” Deputies were
able to free M.R. after getting electrical power to the RV. When deputies
entered the RV, they observed “what appeared to be unsuitable living
conditions for children” inside. Various objects, such as “trash, miscellaneous
boxes, electrical tools, [and] food items” were cluttering the RV floor, and
there was “not much room to move around inside the RV due to all the
clutter.” The floors were dirty, and stains that “appeared to be blood” were
observed on the ceiling. The RV had a “foul odor.” Two cats and a large dog
2
The following facts are taken from the reports prepared by the
Orange County Social Services Agency (Agency) which were admitted into
evidence at the jurisdiction and disposition hearing, discussed post.
3
M.R. informed the Agency he identifies as male and uses male
pronouns. We will use M.R.’s chosen pronouns.
3
were also living in the RV. Father told deputies the blood stains occurred
when he was bitten by a dog. Sheriff’s deputies noted both children “had
unkempt messy/dirty hair, no shoes, dirty feet and dirt underneath their
fingernails, and wore dirty clothes which gave the appearance [they] had not
bathed[/]showered for some time and did not have spare clean clothing to
wear.” A social worker who later contacted both children on the same day
noted each had “visibly greasy” hair, with “blackened dirt” under their finger
and toe nails.
At some point, on August 8, 2023, the children ran into the
maternal grandfather’s home. Sheriff’s deputies reported when Father went
inside to retrieve the children, the maternal grandfather “yelled out and
stated the father was being very aggressive.” Father also reportedly refused
to cooperate with the sheriff’s deputies and would not let them enter the RV.
The deputies arrested Father and placed the children in protective custody.
They were temporarily detained at the Orangewood Children and Family
Center before being placed with their paternal grandmother.
When interviewed by a social worker on August 8, 2023, Mother
stated she had “an accidental exposure to an opioid and she has been trying
to figure out how something like this could happen.” She later stated, in the
same interview, her accidental opioid exposure may have been due to
“Michelle,” a woman she explained was an addict who had stayed in the RV
with them, and was last with them on August 7, 2023. Father wanted to help
Michelle quit drugs and had obtained an opioid dependency treatment drug
for her. Mother denied any history of drug or alcohol abuse. Mother stated
when she started having difficulty breathing, she believed she was having an
incident of heart failure, similar to a past condition for which she was
hospitalized. After her hospitalization, Mother was on permanent disability
4
and had a weak heart. Father had been acting as her paid full-time
caregiver.
When Father was interviewed by the social worker on August 8,
2023, he indicated he was surprised Narcan revived Mother because he
believed she had not taken any opioids. Father indicated Mother “is very
careful because of her heart condition.”
During its investigation, the Agency noted multiple relatives had
expressed concerns as to Father’s drug use history. The paternal
grandmother reported to the social worker that when Father was growing up
he “moved from relative to relative after a divorce and then began using
drugs.” The paternal aunt indicated to the social worker she was concerned
because Father’s current behavior “is how he acted the first time when he
was on drugs.” Additionally, a January 2022 Orange County Sheriff’s
Department record indicated the maternal aunt had requested a welfare
check on the children due to her concern Father was using
methamphetamine and was abusive. When asked by the social worker,
Father denied any current or past substance abuse issues.
The Agency also noted Mother had called the Orange County
Sheriff’s Department in June 2023 to report an incident of domestic violence
perpetrated by Father. According to the sheriff’s report for that incident,
Mother told deputies she had squirted dish soap on Father during an
argument. In response, Father “grabbed and scratched her face with his
nails,” and bit Mother on her arm, hand, and pinky finger. Father then
pushed Mother to the ground. Mother also told the deputies Father tried to
close the sliding glass door on her and grabbed a solar panel, which hit her on
the forehead. Father then pointed an airsoft gun at Mother but did not shoot.
5
Mother jumped out of the RV’s window and ran to a nearby hotel to call law
enforcement.
Sheriff’s deputies who responded to the June 2023 incident
observed visible injuries to Mother’s forehead. She also had two bite marks
on her right arm, left hand and pinky, and scratches on her neck and back.
Mother declined the deputies’ offers for medical attention, prosecution, or an
emergency protective order. Two days later, Mother called the sheriff’s
department to request an emergency protective order and the prosecution of
Father. Mother reported she and the children were then staying in a hotel.
Mother’s request for an emergency protective order was denied because the
parents were no longer living together.
When interviewed by the social worker on August 8, 2023,
Mother “denied any current domestic violence issues.” She reported she and
Father had worked out their problems and the June 2023 incident was
simply a misunderstanding. During this interview, Mother suggested she
and Father were different from other couples because she is strong and she
and Father are trained in advanced martial arts. She stated she was not in
any danger and did not fear Father. During his interview with the social
worker on August 8, 2023, Father also denied any domestic violence occurred
in the home. Additionally, Father explained he was upset at the maternal
grandfather earlier that day as he believes the maternal grandfather abused
Mother as a child.4
4
A few weeks later, Father sent text messages to the social
worker denying allegations he was “aggressive” at the time of the incident on
August 8, 2023. He also provided an audio recording he posted on YouTube
purportedly taken at the time of the incident.
6
When interviewed by social workers on August 8 and 9, 2023,
both children reported they have heard their parents yelling at each other
during arguments. Mc.R. indicated, although he has not seen the parents hit
each other during these fights, he knows they do as he has heard each ask,
“‘[W]hy did you hit me[?]’” Mc.R. reported having seen Mother with a
nosebleed after the parents were fighting. He also saw Mother with a “very
large bump” on her head about a month earlier, which Father said happened
when he accidentally slid a solar panel at Mother. M.R. stated the parents
mostly yell, but “sometimes fight with their bodies.” M.R. told the social
worker a “big fight” happened in June when Mother got a bump on her head
because something fell onto it. M.R. indicated the parents had been fighting
more often lately and Mc.R. stated the fights were getting worse. M.R. told
the social worker his parents had fought on August 8 and the family dog bit
Father’s hand. In a later interview with a different social worker, M.R. also
reported he had seen “scarring and bruising on both” parents due to
“domestic violence.”
On August 17, 2023, M.R. told a social worker “‘[t]he shower [in
the RV] didn’t work, and [they] did not have a sewer system.’” M.R. also
initially told the social worker his family had food, but in a subsequent
interview, he stated they did not always have enough food at home because
the parents would run out of money on their EBT card. He further reported
there were maggots in the refrigerator so they “‘ate out a lot.’” Mother later
confirmed with the social worker the freezer had stopped working and the
food spoiled, but she indicated when she realized this, “‘it stopped’” and “‘[the
food] hadn’t even been there that long.’” Father indicated to the social
worker the RV had a fresh water tank and electricity from solar panels. He
7
explained the “mess inside the RV” was because the RV had been recently
impounded and the impound lot “messed everything up inside.”
The children reported to the social workers Father homeschooled
them, but they had not done “‘school in months.’” According to the social
worker, the children appeared to lack basic communication and writing skills
appropriate for their ages. The social worker noted, when asked to write
their names and dates of birth, both children struggled to complete the task,
and Mc.R. needed to ask M.R. when Mc.R.’s birthday was. The parents
reported the children had not seen a doctor or dentist for three to five years.
The children were placed with their paternal grandmother, where
they reported feeling safe and comfortable. They initially struggled with
attending a regular school, but eventually performed well academically.
The Agency reported concerns the parents were attempting to
coach the children on multiple occasions. In September 2023, the paternal
grandmother told the social worker Father called a few days prior and told
the children they “‘all need to have the same story.’” The paternal
grandmother also reported finding the children talking to Mother at 3:30 a.m.
without the paternal grandmother’s knowledge, and M.R. was upset as his
parents told him “‘to change [his] story’” because they all needed to “‘have the
same story.’”
The parents were thereafter informed by a social worker all
future electronic communication would be supervised by Agency staff due to
“disparag[ing] comments made in a contact between the parents and the
children . . . .” The social worker reiterated to the parents not to discuss the
court case with the children and to refrain from having any unsupervised
online contact. At a subsequent hearing regarding the parents’ visitation, the
court reiterated its order to the parents through counsel that they are “not to
8
discuss any aspect of this case with [the children], as previously ordered.” A
few days after this hearing, the paternal grandmother reported finding text
messages from Father on Mc.R.’s cell phone that he was coming to pick up
the children, and to, “‘Get your stories straight because things are not as bad
as it seems when we were younger.’” Father later acknowledged to the social
worker he had violated court orders by texting the children, but claimed
Mother was not involved. Father had also allegedly been calling and verbally
5
harassing the paternal grandmother.
Per the Agency’s reports, there was uncertainty as to where the
parents were living from August through November 2023. They provided
multiple addresses and sometimes failed to inform the social workers of
changes in their address. In November 2023, Mother reported she and
Father had signed a rental agreement for an apartment in Lake Forest. She
5
In text messages to the social worker on October 19, 2023,
Father denied the paternal grandmother’s reports regarding Father’s
behavior. Father also texted, among other statements, “‘The system and our
family abandoned us and then we are punished for the results despite our
greatest effort to stabilize.’” After the social worker explained a child welfare
case could last from “6 months to 1.5 years,” Father responded, “‘Nope that is
not okay with me. Sorry. But I’m taking them back then. I’m being straight
out with it. We are moving up north today.’” When the social worker
explained he could not advise Father on what to do, but if Father showed up
at the paternal grandmother’s home unauthorized, law enforcement would be
contacted, Father responded, “‘Progress? CPS kidnapped my kids while I was
wrongfully detained.’” He also texted, “‘If you can’t undo what has been
wrongfully done. That is insane. This so called process is a bunch of people
shuffling around paper. That’s what landed us in this mess in the first
place.’” (Italics have been removed in the quotations of Father’s texts in this
footnote.)
9
provided the social worker with their new address and invited the social
worker to schedule a home assessment.
In December 2023, a social worker went to the parents’
apartment for the assessment. The social worker knocked on the door but
there was no response. She called and texted Mother, who did not respond.
When Mother arrived, she indicated she had forgotten her key and needed to
call her landlord. The social worker suggested Mother go to the apartment
leasing office so she could be let back into the apartment, but Mother refused.
Instead, Mother informed the worker she had to leave to get the key from
Father and would return. The worker informed Mother she would wait for
Mother’s return. When the social worker later returned to the apartment,
Mother let the worker inside.6
Although Mother denied anyone else was present in the
apartment, the social worker observed a man on the couch under a blanket.
Mother stated he was her landlord and was napping because he was sick.
Mother stated his name was “Saul” but could not recall his last name. It
appeared to the social worker that much younger children lived in the
apartment due to the presence of toys and unfamiliar names written on the
wall. The social worker could not determine whether Mother was living in
the apartment. Mother indicated she was subletting the apartment and,
when the social worker asked Mother for a copy of the lease, Mother stated
she would find a copy. A child welfare referral search for that Lake Forest
6
At the time of the assessment, Mother told the social worker
Father was not on the lease, he lived in the RV, and she and Father were not
together. Mother also indicated, if she was asked to get a restraining order
against Father, she would not do so because “‘he needs to be [her] caregiver.’”
10
apartment revealed a recent referral as of Mother’s purported landlord, Saul,
involving mental health issues and domestic violence.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I.
CHILD WELFARE PETITION
On August 11, 2023, the Agency filed a child welfare petition,
alleging the children came within the jurisdiction of the court under section
300. The factual allegations in the petition pursuant to section 300,
subdivision (b)(1), as later amended by interlineation (the amended petition),
were as follows: (1) Mother had an unresolved problem with substance abuse,
including, but not limited to, “fentanyl and/or other opioids,” based on the
August 8, 2023 episode in which she was revived by multiple doses of Narcan;
(2) Father had a history of substance abuse, which may include, but was not
limited to, methamphetamine, and “which may be an unresolved problem”;
(3) the parents failed to ensure the children had a safe and sanitary home
environment as the RV was described as unsanitary with hazardous
conditions; (4) Mother had unresolved mental health issues; (5) Father had
unresolved anger management and/or mental health issues; (6) the parents
had exposed the children to domestic violence; and (7) Mother had a criminal
conviction and/or arrest for driving under the influence.
II.
DETENTION REPORT AND HEARING
Neither parent appeared for the detention hearing in August
2023, and the matter was continued for three days at their counsel’s request.
Neither parent appeared for the rescheduled hearing. Parents’ counsel
claimed Mother had gone to the hospital and requested a one-day
11
continuance, which was granted. Mother then appeared the next day, but
Father failed to appear.
At the detention hearing, the court found the Agency had made a
prima facie showing the continued detention of the children was necessary.
(§ 319.) The court ordered weekly supervised visitation for both parents, as
well as electronic communication. The parents were ordered not to discuss
any aspect of the case with the children. The court encouraged the parents to
engage in the “programs, therapy and other services the social worker will be
offering.”
III.
JURISDICTION AND DISPOSITION HEARING
The juvenile court conducted a combined jurisdiction and
disposition hearing on multiple dates in November and December 2023.
Father was absent from nearly every hearing date, while Mother appeared
more regularly, although she also missed a few hearing dates. At the end of
the hearing, the court received seven Agency reports into evidence.7 The
Agency’s recommendation in each of those reports remained the same: for
the court to sustain the petition as to the children, declare them dependents,
and order family reunification services. The court also received Mother’s
exhibits identified as “A through M.” In addition, the court heard testimony
from Mother, M.R., Mc.R., and two social workers at the hearing.
7
These reports were: (1) Jurisdiction/Disposition Report, dated
September 19, 2023; (2) Addendum Report, dated October 3, 2023; (3)
Addendum Report #2, dated October 24, 2023; (4) Addendum Report #3,
dated November 1, 2023; (5) Addendum Report #4, dated November 22, 2023;
(6) Redacted Addendum Report #5, dated December 4, 2023; (7) Addendum
Report #6, dated December 6, 2023; and (8) Addendum Report #7, dated
December 6, 2023.
12
During Mother’s testimony, she denied using fentanyl, opioids or
methamphetamine, indicating she had only used marijuana to address her
medical issues and had done so no more recently than 2021. Mother stated
she would only use marijuana outside the presence of the children. She
denied overdosing on fentanyl on August 8, 2023, denied having been
accidentally exposed to fentanyl, and denied telling M.R. she had ingested
candy with fentanyl on it. Mother acknowledged initially telling a social
worker she may have been exposed to fentanyl through Michelle, their
houseguest, who Mother stated had a “history of fentanyl use.” However,
Mother said this was only a suspicion of hers and her drug tests after the
August 8 incident have come back negative.8 Mother acknowledged Michelle
had “a history of fentanyl use,” but denied having ever left the children alone
with Michelle.
As for their home, Mother testified the RV “was safe and
sanitary, meaning there were no physical hazards, no chemical hazards,
[and] no emotional hazards.” Mother also stated she slept at her new Lake
Forest apartment but spent her days with Father. Mother indicated she had
not yet provided the sublease agreement to the social worker, but she could
do so.9
8
In the Agency’s Jurisdiction/Disposition Report, Mother
reportedly told a social worker, who interviewed Mother on August 28, 2023,
her medical file for the August 8 incident states it was an “‘accidental
exposure.’” Mother reported being drug tested in the emergency room one
week after the August 8 incident and “no drugs were found in her system
then.”
9
A copy of Mother’s sublease agreement was later marked and
admitted into evidence at the hearing.
13
As to her relationship with Father, Mother testified she “would
mainly yell” which “would trigger him to also yell back,” but this was “the
only thing that qualifies as aggressive,” and Mother indicated she was
working on her yelling. An incident during which Father broke M.R.’s cell
phone was an isolated event according to Mother, and Father was not mad at
M.R. at that time. Mother also stated “[a]nytime [Father] would have
stricken me it would have been consensual because, again, we’re martial
artists . . . like to the outside world, play fighting doesn’t look like play
fighting. To us it’s play fighting. Sparring looks like fighting, but to us it’s
training.” She said as martial artists she and Father would hit each other,
and sometimes there would be a little blood. According to Mother, the
children never witnessed any sort of physical domestic violence between her
and Father.
Mother also testified she had started parenting and domestic
violence classes in October 2023, but had not participated in drug testing.
Mother stated she was willing to sign releases of information regarding the
August 8, 2023 incident, but had not been asked to do so by the social
workers.
Mc.R. testified he would change clothes about once a week when
he lived in the RV. He denied seeing the parents use drugs except he had
sometimes been around Mother when she smoked marijuana. Mc.R. has seen
Michelle smoke marijuana with a “bong.” Mc.R. would sometimes see his
parents and Michelle smoke marijuana together. He has also sometimes
been left alone with Michelle during the day.
Mc.R. acknowledged the parents would yell at each other and
may have hit each other, but he “never really saw” this. He stated he felt “a
little” scared when the parents argued. He testified his parents fought
14
“[v]ery often, like twice a week,” and he has seen bruising on Mother. Mc.R.
further testified he wanted to return home despite the parents’ fighting as he
loved them. Mc.R. confirmed Father had texted urging him to lie to the social
workers.
M.R. testified he wanted to go home with his parents, “but not in
the condition [they] were in before.” According to M.R., the home was dirty,
sometimes they ate only once a day, and sometimes he would go a “month or
weeks” without changing clothes. M.R. was sometimes scared by the parents’
arguments and the parents would sometimes involve the children in such
arguments. M.R. was aware of instances when the parents’ arguments would
get physical, resulting in injuries to both. M.R. has seen “bite marks” on
Mother’s shoulder and hand. Mother told the children Father had bitten her
during one of their fights. M.R. testified, during the incident involving the
solar panel, Father took M.R.’s cell phone so Mother could not call the police.
When M.R. asked Father to return the phone, Father “got mad and smashed
it against the wall” and then against the kitchen sink’s faucet. M.R.
indicated Father told the children to “fix up our stories.”
As for the incident on August 8, 2023, M.R. remembered telling a
social worker Mother had eaten a candy with fentanyl on it. M.R. indicated
Mother told the children she had “flipped a table while they were fighting”
and “drugs got knocked onto the candy and then she ate it.” Mother told
M.R. the drugs were something Michelle had left in the RV. M.R. also has
seen “white crystals in a little Pokemon bag” his parents had. M.R. had not
seen Mother use any drugs.
Two social workers were called for purposes of cross-examination
regarding their reports; both were questioned as to the parents’ services. The
first social worker also testified that although the parents had indicated the
15
RV had been renovated, the parents had not made the RV, in which they
were living, available for assessment and no photos had been provided as to
its renovated status. The second social worker testified the Agency had
provided “drug testing information” to both parents but neither parent had
yet submitted to drug testing.
On December 7, 2023, the court sustained the amended petition,
declared the children dependents of the juvenile court, and removed custody
of them from both parents. Family reunification services were ordered by the
court for both parents. The parents filed separate, timely notices of appeal.
DISCUSSION
Both parents contend the juvenile court’s jurisdictional and
dispositional orders removing the children from parental custody are
unsupported by substantial evidence.10 We disagree.
I.
THE JURISDICTIONAL FINDINGS ARE SUPPORTED BY SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
The juvenile court asserted jurisdiction over the children
pursuant to section 300, subdivision (b)(1). A juvenile court may exercise
jurisdiction under this section if the court finds by a preponderance of the
evidence that, as relevant here, “there is a substantial risk that the child will
suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of . . . [¶] . . . [t]he failure
or inability of the child’s parent . . . to adequately supervise or protect the
child. [¶] . . . [¶] . . . [and/or] [t]he willful or negligent failure of the
parent . . . to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or
10
Although Mother and Father filed separate appellate briefs,
they joined in each other’s arguments on appeal, so we will address their
contentions together.
16
medical treatment.” (§ 300, subd. (b)(1)(A) & (C); see In re Joaquin C. (2017)
15 Cal.App.5th 537, 561.) “‘Facts supporting allegations that a child is one
described by section 300 are cumulative.’ [Citation.] Thus, the court ‘must
consider all the circumstances affecting the child, wherever they occur.’” (In
re T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 133.)
The parents both contend the evidence was insufficient to
support child welfare jurisdiction because “there was no evidence of a current
risk of substantial harm” to the children at the time of the jurisdiction
hearing. A juvenile court’s jurisdictional finding can be affirmed on review
“‘if any one of the statutory bases for jurisdiction that are enumerated in the
petition is supported by substantial evidence.’” (In re I.J. (2013) 56 Cal.4th
766, 773.) The reviewing court “‘need not consider whether any or all of the
other alleged statutory grounds for jurisdiction are supported by the
evidence.’” (Ibid.)
“A jurisdictional finding that the minor is a person described in
section 300 must be made by at least a preponderance of the evidence.
[Citations.] ‘We review the jurisdictional findings for substantial evidence.
[Citation.] We consider the entire record, drawing all reasonable inferences
in support of the juvenile court’s findings and affirming the order even if
other evidence supports a different finding. [Citation.] We do not consider
the credibility of witnesses or reweigh the evidence.’ [Citation.] ‘The parent
has the burden on appeal of showing there is insufficient evidence to support
the juvenile court’s order.’” (In re L.B. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 402, 411–412.)
Paragraph b-6 of the amended petition alleged the parents “have
exposed the children” to “domestic violence.” The parents argue a finding of
jurisdiction based on domestic violence also requires a showing of a “threat of
harm to the children’s physical safety.” Father acknowledges “there was no
17
dispute that the parents had many verbal arguments.” Mother argues she
and the children reported the incident involving the solar panel as “an
accident.” She also points to her testimony the parents engaged in “‘play
fights’” as part of their martial arts training. In any event, both parents
assert the children were not physically harmed or at “substantial risk of
suffering serious physical harm” due to domestic violence as of the date of the
jurisdiction hearing.
Relying on the children’s testimony, the juvenile court found the
parents had engaged in domestic violence and Mother was “in denial” as to
the domestic violence between the parents. The fact the children did not
suffer physical injury does not negate the substantial harm caused by these
acts of domestic violence. “‘The court need not wait until a child is seriously
abused or injured to assume jurisdiction and take the steps necessary to
protect the child.’ [Citations.] It is well settled that physical violence
between a child’s parents may support the exercise of jurisdiction under
subdivision (b)(1) of section 300 where there is evidence that the domestic
violence has placed the child at risk of physical harm and the violence is
ongoing or likely to recur.” (In re L.B., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at p. 411.)
“The relevant inquiry under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), is
whether circumstances at the time of the jurisdictional hearing “‘“subject the
minor to the defined risk of harm.”’ [Citation.] ‘The court may consider past
events in deciding whether a child currently needs the court’s protection.’
[Citations.] Indeed, in a domestic violence situation, past violence is highly
probative of the risk that violence may recur. [Citation.] To establish a
defined risk of harm at the time of the hearing, there ‘“must be some reason
beyond mere speculation to believe the alleged conduct will recur.”’” (In re
L.B., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th at p. 411.)
18
In sustaining the amended petition’s allegations, the juvenile
court “heavily rel[ied] on the children’s testimony” finding “their testimony to
be accurate and credible, both historically and currently.” Both children
testified to hearing their parents fight and of being aware these altercations
were at times physical, with both describing injuries they later observed on
Mother. The children testified these incidents of domestic violence were
recent, ongoing, and worsening in severity. Mc.R. told the juvenile court his
parents fought “[v]ery often,” and he has seen bruising on Mother. M.R.
reported seeing “bite marks” on Mother’s hand that Mother said were
because Father had bitten her. M.R. reported the fights between the parents
were getting worse. Both children also testified they were sometimes scared
when these incidents occurred, and M.R. indicated at times the parents
involved the children in their arguments. M.R. testified during the “one big
fight with the solar panel,” Father smashed his cell phone because Father did
not want Mother to call the police.
Thus, based on the risk of harm arising from the parents’
continuous cycle of domestic violence described by the children, and viewing
the facts in the light most favorable to the court’s decision below, substantial
evidence supports the court’s jurisdictional order. Additionally, since
jurisdiction was proper as to the domestic violence allegation, we need not
address the parents’ other challenges to jurisdiction.
II.
THE DISPOSITIONAL FINDINGS ARE SUPPORTED BY SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
The parents also contend there is insufficient evidence to support
the juvenile court’s removal order and further contend the court failed to
consider reasonable alternatives to removal.
19
Before the court may order a child removed from his or her
parent, it must find, by clear and convincing evidence, “[t]here is or would be
a substantial danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being of the [child] if the [child] were returned home, and
there are no reasonable means by which the [child’s] physical health can be
protected without” removal. (§ 361, subd. (c)(1).) “The parent need not be
dangerous, and the [child] need not have been actually harmed” for removal
to be appropriate. (In re Diamond H. (2000) 82 Cal.App.4th 1127, 1136,
disapproved on another ground in Renee J. v. Superior Court (2001) 26
Cal.4th 735, 748, fn. 6.) “The focus of the statute is on averting harm to the
child.” (In re Diamond H., supra, 82 Cal.App.4th at p. 1136.)
“[W]hen reviewing a finding that a fact has been proved by clear
and convincing evidence, the question before the appellate court is whether
the record as a whole contains substantial evidence from which a reasonable
fact finder could have found it highly probable that the fact was true.
Consistent with well-established principles governing review for sufficiency of
the evidence, in making this assessment the appellate court must view the
record in the light most favorable to the prevailing party below and give due
deference to how the trier of fact may have evaluated the credibility of
witnesses, resolved conflicts in the evidence, and drawn reasonable
inferences from the evidence.” (Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989,
995–996.)
Substantial evidence supports the court’s finding, by clear and
convincing evidence, the parents’ domestic violence posed a substantial risk
of harm to the children as they were exposed to a continuous cycle of recent
domestic violence between the parents. However, the parents argue the
evidence was insufficient to remove the children from their custody because
20
the children were not “at substantial risk of being physically harmed.”
Mother also specifically argues there was insufficient evidence to support the
court’s order removing the children from her care.
Although the children testified they never saw physical violence
between the parents, they heard multiple acts of such violence, and observed
injuries as a result. They were also sometimes frightened by the abuse.
“Studies show that violence by one parent against another harms children
even if they do not witness it.” (Fields, The Impact of Spouse Abuse on
Children and Its Relevance in Custody and Visitation Decisions in New York
State (1994) 3 Cornell J.L. & Pub. Policy 221, 228, fn. omitted.) “Even if a
child suffers no physical harm due to domestic violence, a ‘cycle of violence
between . . . parents constitute[s] a failure to protect [a child] “from the
substantial risk of encountering the violence and suffering serious physical
harm or illness from it.”’” (In re V.L. (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 147, 156.)
Additionally, the juvenile court found Mother to be “in denial” as
to the parents’ domestic violence. “A parent’s denial of domestic violence
increases the risk of it recurring.” (In re V.L., supra, 54 Cal.App.5th at p.
156.) Here, the parents failed to acknowledge the harm to the children
because they largely denied or minimized the domestic violence. Mother
tried to explain away the violence by asserting the parents were merely
engaged in practicing their advanced martial arts skills, even though Mother
also reportedly suffered from a serious heart condition and required full-time
care by Father. Mother additionally downplayed the domestic violence
despite documentation by law enforcement of her physical injuries, which
included bites, bruising, and scratches she received during the June 2023
incident. She also took the blame for triggering the parents’ arguments.
Based on the evidence regarding the parents’ ongoing domestic violence,
21
substantial evidence supports the dispositional order removing the children
from parental custody.
The parents further contend the court erred in failing to consider
reasonable alternatives to removal, such as releasing the children to Mother’s
sole care or having the children’s godfather live with Mother and the
children.
Contrary to the parents’ argument, the court explained in detail
why the children could not be returned at that time to their custody:
“Whether there were reasonable means to avoid removal or to allow the
children to return home, parents have not taken advantage of any of the
resources available to them. Mother has not signed a release to allow the
workers to communicate with any programs or get information from any
programs. Mother has not signed a release to access her medical records.
“Mother and [F]ather have limited their contact with the Social
Services Agency. Father has pretty much removed himself from the picture.
Father doesn’t show up for court. They no-show for visits without notice.
“And the failure to follow court orders, which is a demonstrated
pattern, the Court cannot expect people who don’t show up to court when
they are ordered to show up to comply with future court orders.
“The bottom line is neither parent has demonstrated a protective
capacity to protect the children from substance use, neglect, and abuse, and
the conditions of the home and domestic violence.”
The court reasonably relied upon the parents’ failure to cooperate
with the Agency’s investigation, limited engagement in services, and
repeated violations of orders. There was no evidence the parents could or
would change the behavior the court found harmful to their children. Father
neither accepted responsibility nor showed contrition, suggesting to the social
22
workers he believed the child welfare proceedings involving his children were
baseless. Mother minimized the seriousness of her fentanyl overdose, the
condition of the RV, and the ongoing domestic violence, and she blamed
herself for causing any arguments with Father. (In re M.R. (2017) 8
Cal.App.5th 101, 109–110 [juvenile court could consider parents’
minimization of their conduct].) “One cannot correct a problem one fails to
acknowledge.” (In re Gabriel K. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 188, 197.)
Because the juvenile court’s findings underlying the dispositional
order removing the children from parental custody was supported by
evidence sufficient to enable a reasonable fact finder to find it highly probable
the fact was true, we affirm that order. (See Conservatorship of O.B., supra,
9 Cal.5th at pp. 995-996.)
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s jurisdictional and dispositional orders are
affirmed.
MOTOIKE, J.
WE CONCUR:
GOETHALS, ACTING P. J.
GOODING, J.
23
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.